The Burden of Being Exceptional

Introduction: The Price of Success

In today’s world, success is often measured by academic achievements, career milestones, and social recognition. From an early age, students are pushed to excel—not just in studies but in extracurricular activities, leadership roles, and competitive exams. While many achieve remarkable success, the hidden cost is often emotional detachment, mental health struggles, and a loss of cultural values.

This article explores the impact of overachievement on students’ mental well-being, drawing insights from Army Public Schools, Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalayas (JNVs), and the European education model. It also discusses how educators and parents can restore balance through emotional care, counselling, and value-based education. The Burden of Being Exceptional: Balancing Achievement with Emotional Well-being

In the modern world, success is often defined by academic excellence, career achievements, and social recognition. From an early age, children are conditioned to believe that their worth is measured by their grades, ranks, and extracurricular triumphs. Parents invest heavily in education, coaching classes, and extracurricular training, believing that a well-rounded portfolio is the key to a prosperous future. Schools, too, reinforce this mindset by emphasising competition over creativity, emotional intelligence, and self-awareness.

While this approach undoubtedly produces high achievers—doctors, engineers, civil servants, and scholars—it often overlooks an essential aspect of human growth: emotional well-being. Many students who excel in academics struggle with social relationships, emotional attachment, and personal fulfilment. The education system, designed to prepare them for professional success, often fails to equip them with the skills to navigate personal struggles, interpersonal conflicts, and mental health challenges.

The result? A generation of students who achieve greatness on paper but feel lost in life. Some become emotionally detached from their families, some struggle with identity crises, and others develop anxiety and depression due to the overwhelming pressure to perform. The irony is that while parents and teachers work hard to shape a child’s career, they often fail to nurture the child’s emotional depth, mental stability, and moral values.

Having taught at Army Public Schools and Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalayas (JNVs), I have witnessed firsthand how different environments shape students’ personalities and life outcomes. While boarding school students often achieve career success, they tend to become emotionally disconnected from their families. On the other hand, students in caring environments like JNVs receive more attention and emotional support, but societal influences sometimes hinder their mental well-being.

Moreover, as global education models influence India, we find ourselves at a crossroads between Western liberal values and Indian cultural traditions. The European education system, known for its student-centric approach and practical learning, has undeniable strengths, but aspects of its social culture—such as early exposure to sexual relationships and reduced emphasis on family bonds—do not always align with Indian values. The challenge is to adopt the best educational practices from around the world while preserving the emotional, ethical, and cultural values.

By the end of this discussion, it will become clear that success should not come at the cost of emotional well-being. An education system that produces brilliant minds but emotionally disconnected individuals is incomplete. If we want to truly prepare students for life, we must redefine success beyond grades and ranks—prioritising mental health, self-awareness, and strong ethical foundations.

Real Stories behind the Numbers

This is not just a theoretical discussion. The insights in this article come from real classrooms, real conversations, and real students whose smiles often hid silent struggles. As an educator who has taught in institutions like Army Public School and Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya, I’ve seen firsthand how success stories can carry unseen scars. These are not isolated cases—they reflect a broader truth about our education system, where emotional well-being is often the price of excellence. Army Public Schools: High Achievers, Emotionally Detached. As a former teacher at Army Public School, I observed that students in boarding environments thrive academically. They become disciplined, focused, and driven, often securing positions as engineers, doctors, and officers. Many became highly independent but struggled with expressing emotions in personal relationships. Case Study: The Lost Parental Bond – A Doctor’s Struggle with Emotional Connection

During my time at Army Public School, I encountered a student named Aditya (name changed), a disciplined and exceptionally bright individual. From a young age, Aditya showed remarkable dedication to academics and extracurricular activities. His schedule was meticulously planned—morning drills, intensive study sessions, leadership training, and extracurricular pursuits. By the time he reached Grade 12, he had become one of the top achievers in his batch, securing an impressive NEET rank and gaining admission into a prestigious medical college.

However, his emotional struggles became evident after he transitioned to adulthood. When Aditya returned home after years of rigorous schooling and hostel life, he felt emotionally distant from his family. His parents, who had sacrificed so much for his education, were eager to reconnect, but Aditya found it difficult to express warmth, affection, or even engage in deep conversations with them. He confessed, “I respect them for what they’ve done for me, but I don’t feel close to them. My teachers were my real family. It feels odd to call home for anything other than financial needs.”His mother, heartbroken, once confided in me, “We wanted him to succeed, but we didn’t realise we were losing him emotionally. He comes home, but he’s not really here with us. It’s like we raised a stranger.”

This case highlights a growing issue in high-achievement-oriented educational systems: the unintended emotional detachment between students and their families. The structured and competitive nature of Army Public Schools instils discipline, resilience, and ambition. However, the lack of consistent parental presence means students often form their primary emotional attachments with teachers, house wardens, or peers rather than with their own families.

Bridging the Emotional Gap case underscores the necessity for parents to not only focus on their child’s career but also nurture their emotional well-being. Schools and hostels must also integrate structured emotional care programs, such as:

Parental involvement programs: Schools should encourage frequent, meaningful interactions between students and parents through video calls, letters, or structured family visits beyond occasional holidays.
Emotional literacy workshops: These can help students understand and express their feelings, reinforcing the importance of relationships outside of academic success.
Mentorship beyond academics: Teachers should act not only as academic guides but also as emotional mentors, ensuring students do not completely detach from their families.

Success without emotional depth can lead to isolation in adulthood. If students like Aditya are to thrive holistically, educators and parents must prioritise emotional intelligence as much as academic excellence.

Case Study: The Lost Parental Bond

A bright student from Army Public School cleared NEET on his first attempt and became a doctor. However, when he returned home, he felt disconnected from his parents. He shared, “I respect them, but I don’t feel close. My teachers were my family.”

This highlights the need for parents to not just invest in their child’s education but also in their emotional well-being. Success without emotional grounding can lead to isolation in adulthood. The Silent Achiever: When Success Comes at the Cost of Connection. Aryan had always been an exceptional student. From a young age, his parents envisioned a bright future for him—one filled with academic excellence, prestigious college admissions, and a successful career. To ensure he stayed on the right path, they enrolled him in Army Public School’s boarding program, believing that a disciplined environment would mould him into a high achiever. Life in the hostel was structured and demanding, but Aryan thrived. His days began before sunrise, packed with drills, classes, assignments, and competitive exam preparation. His teachers praised him for his dedication, and his classmates admired his work ethic. At home, his parents took pride in his achievements, convinced that every sacrifice was justified for the sake of his future.

But with each passing year, Aryan’s visits home grew shorter. When he did return, he spent most of his time buried in books, preparing for entrance exams rather than engaging with his family. His parents saw his silence as focus, his distance as maturity. They reassured themselves that he was simply too busy building his future to indulge in idle chatter.

When Aryan finally cracked JEE Advanced with a top rank and secured admission into one of India’s premier engineering colleges, his parents couldn’t contain their joy. Relatives and neighbours congratulated them, praising their son’s brilliance and discipline. The family home buzzed with celebration, but beneath the surface, an unsettling truth remained unnoticed.

After years away, Aryan returned home for an extended break before college. His mother prepared his favourite meals, hoping to relive the warmth of his childhood. His father proudly planned a small gathering to honour his achievements. But when Aryan arrived, the house felt unfamiliar to him. The walls that had once echoed with his laughter now seemed distant. His Childhood room, carefully arranged by his mother, felt like a museum of a life he barely remembered.

At the dinner table, he ate in silence, glancing at his phone between bites. His mother gently reminded him of how he used to demand extra servings of rajma chawal, but he responded with a faint, detached smile. His father, eager to discuss his future, asked about his college plans. Aryan answered in short, mechanical sentences, his mind already elsewhere. The warmth that once filled their conversations had faded.

That night, as his mother cleared the dishes, she turned to her husband and whispered, “He feels like a guest in his own home.” Her voice trembled as she fought back tears. “We gave him everything, but why does it feel like we lost him?”

Aryan wasn’t ungrateful. He wasn’t distant out of resentment. He simply didn’t know how to connect anymore. Years of structured discipline had trained him to be independent, self-sufficient, and focused. But in the process, he had lost something crucial—the ability to belong. His teachers had become his family, his hostel had become his home, and the people who had sacrificed everything for him now felt like strangers.

His story is not unique. Across boarding schools and high-pressure academic environments, countless students grow into accomplished professionals yet struggle with emotional isolation. Their success is undeniable, but so is their detachment. The very system designed to shape them into achievers often neglects to prepare them for something just as important—human connection.

For parents and educators, Aryan’s story serves as a reminder that success should never come at the cost of emotional well-being. Academic achievement is important, but so is fostering a sense of belonging. Conversations at home should go beyond grades and career goals, focusing on emotions, fears, and personal growth. Schools must balance discipline with warmth, ensuring that students feel valued not just for their performance but for who they are. A child’s future is built not just in classrooms and exam halls but also in the quiet moments of family life—through shared laughter, open conversations, and the reassurance that no matter how far they go, home will always be more than just a place.

JNVs: A Stronger Support System but Troubling Societal Influences

During my time teaching at JNV Chandigarh and Fazilka, I noticed a different pattern. JNVs provide greater care, personal attention, and a family-like environment, which helps students excel. However, external societal factors affected their mental stability. Many JNV students come from diverse backgrounds, and while they receive a good education, societal influences disrupt their emotional and ethical development. JNVs: A Stronger Support System but Troubling Societal Influences

Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalayas (JNVs) have long been recognised as a beacon of quality education for students from rural India. These institutions provide not only academic excellence but also a nurturing, family-like environment that fosters personal growth. Unlike conventional schools, JNVs offer residential schooling, where students form strong bonds with peers and teachers, creating a close-knit community. The structured routine, personal attention, and moral guidance play a crucial role in shaping responsible individuals.

However, despite the strong support system within JNVs, the reality outside these institutions tells a different story. Many students, especially those from underprivileged backgrounds, struggle with emotional conflicts as they navigate between the disciplined school environment and the harsh societal influences they encounter at home. The clash of values, cultural expectations, and external pressures often disrupts their mental stability, making it difficult to strike a balance between their school life and their personal reality.

One of the key challenges lies in family expectations. Many JNV students come from households where education is viewed as a means to financial stability rather than personal development. Parents, though proud of their child’s achievements, often fail to provide emotional support. Conversations revolve around marks, ranks, and career goals, leaving little room for personal bonding. As a result, many students feel alienated when they return home, struggling to reconnect with their families. They respect their parents but find themselves emotionally distant, as their school environment has shaped them into individuals with aspirations and values different from those held by their families.

Beyond family dynamics, societal norms present another layer of complexity. JNVs instil values of discipline, equality, and independent thinking, but once students step outside, they face a world that often contradicts these teachings. Many students return to communities where gender discrimination, caste biases, and rigid traditions still prevail. Their progressive mindset, shaped by years of holistic education, clashes with societal expectations, leaving them feeling isolated. Some attempt to challenge these norms, only to be met with resistance. Others suppress their thoughts, fearing rejection from their own people. This emotional dilemma can take a toll on their confidence, leading to anxiety and self-doubt.

Peer pressure within JNVs adds to the emotional burden. Since students are selected based on merit, they find themselves among some of the brightest minds in the country. While this competitive environment is meant to encourage excellence, it often leads to stress and a constant need to prove oneself. Many students begin to equate their self-worth with academic performance, fearing that any failure might define their future. The pressure to excel, combined with the struggle to balance personal and societal expectations, can be overwhelming.

Rahul, a student from JNV Fazilka, experienced this conflict firsthand. A bright and disciplined student, he thrived in the structured environment of his school. However, every time he visited home, he felt like a stranger. His father, a farmer, believed that too much education was unnecessary and often dismissed his son's dreams as impractical. His mother, deeply rooted in tradition, discouraged him from questioning long-standing customs. Rahul, torn between the values of his school and the expectations of his family, found himself caught in an emotional struggle. He loved his family but felt misunderstood. He respected his roots but wanted to break free from limitations. The emotional tug-of-war left him confused, affecting his mental well-being and self-identity.

Despite these challenges, JNVs have the potential to bridge this emotional gap. More emphasis on parental involvement through counselling sessions can help families understand their children's needs beyond academics. Value-based education should not be limited to moral science classes but integrated into daily interactions, helping students develop resilience against societal pressures. Strengthening mental health support within schools can provide students with a safe space to express their concerns and seek guidance. Alumni mentorship programs can also play a crucial role, offering students real-life examples of how to balance personal growth with external expectations.

The success of JNVs should not be measured solely by academic achievements but also by the emotional well-being of their students. Education should empower individuals not just to secure careers but to lead fulfilling lives where they feel emotionally connected, socially aware, and mentally strong. If JNVs can address these societal challenges, they will not only produce successful professionals but also emotionally resilient individuals who can create meaningful change in their communities. Finding a Balanced Approach

Sexual orientation is a personal aspect of an individual’s life, and every student deserves respect and dignity. However, the growing identity conflicts in JNVs highlight the need for structured guidance to prevent confusion and emotional distress. The goal should not be to suppress conversations but to provide the right kind of moral and psychological support so that students understand themselves in a healthy and informed manner.

JNVs need to take proactive steps to address this issue:

Introduce Trained Counsellors – Professional mental health experts should be available to guide students through emotional challenges.
Strengthen Value-Based Education – Schools should reinforce ethical and moral teachings that promote self-discipline, mutual respect, and emotional clarity.
Encourage Healthy Discussions – Instead of treating these topics as taboo, JNVs should create a safe space where students can discuss personal struggles with trusted mentors.
Parental Involvement – Parents should be educated on the emotional and psychological challenges their children face so they can provide support at home.
Holistic Development Programs – Workshops on personal identity, decision-making, and social behaviour should be included in the curriculum to help students develop a balanced perspective.

JNVs have always been a model of discipline and excellence. However, as society evolves, these institutions must also adapt by offering structured emotional and moral guidance. Addressing identity conflicts with sensitivity, education, and proper mentorship can ensure that students grow into confident individuals who are mentally strong, socially responsible, and emotionally secure.

European Education vs. Indian Values

The European education system promotes practical learning, stress-free schooling, and student independence. However, one aspect that does not align with Indian culture is its openness in sexual relationships from a young age. While European students receive sex education and freedom, its unregulated influence can have negative impacts in an Indian setting. European Education vs. Indian Values: A Cultural Dilemma

The European education system is widely regarded for its focus on practical learning, stress-free schooling, and student independence. It encourages critical thinking, self-exploration, and a balanced approach to academics and extracurricular activities. However, when we Compare it with Indian values, a significant cultural clash emerges—especially in the area of openness in relationships and sexual education.

While European societies emphasise early sex education, relationship freedom, and personal choice, the same approach can lead to serious challenges in an Indian context. India, being a culturally rooted society, places strong emphasis on family honour, moral discipline, and controlled social interactions between genders. When unfiltered Western influences enter the Indian mindset, they often create identity confusion, social stigma, and personal distress.
Examples of Shame and Social Conflict in an Indian Setting

The Clash of Family Honour and Relationship Openness

In many European countries, teenagers are encouraged to explore relationships freely, even at an early age. Parents are often open to their children dating and even cohabiting before marriage. However, in India, where family honour (izzat) is deeply ingrained, such openness can lead to shame and social backlash.

For instance, there have been multiple cases where young couples from conservative families faced severe consequences for engaging in relationships. Some students who embraced Western ideals of freedom found themselves ostracised, shamed, or even subjected to honour-based restrictions. In extreme cases, societal pressure has led to forced marriages, disownment, or even violence.

Premarital Relationships and Their Consequences

In the West, relationships before marriage are considered normal. However, in India, premarital intimacy—especially for women—carries a stigma that can affect their social reputation and even their prospects of marriage. Many young individuals, influenced by Western media and education, have faced shame and rejection from their own families and communities when their relationships became public.

For example, cases of students engaging in secret relationships and later being subjected to parental intervention, humiliation, or even forced separation are not uncommon. Many young women have found themselves struggling between Western ideals of freedom and Indian societal expectations, often leading to mental distress and family conflicts.

The Struggles of Single Motherhood and Social Rejection

In European societies, single motherhood is widely accepted, and government policies support such individuals with financial and social benefits. In contrast, in India, unmarried mothers often face severe social stigma, economic struggles, and emotional distress.

There have been instances where young women, unaware of the consequences of their choices, found themselves abandoned by partners and shamed by their families. The absence of a support system and fear of social rejection have led to cases of depression, forced marriages, or even suicides. Unlike the West, where such situations are handled with maturity and institutional backing, Indian society largely reacts with judgment and exclusion.

Influence on Young Students and Disruptions in Academic Focus

In Western education systems, students are given complete freedom over their personal choices. However, in India, where academic success is paramount, an unregulated influence of relationship freedom has, in some cases, led students to lose focus on their studies.

There are examples where students, caught up in relationships influenced by Western ideals, have neglected their education, faced mental distress, or even dropped out due to social or parental pressure. The lack of balanced guidance on handling relationships, emotions, and personal discipline in an Indian context makes young individuals vulnerable to making hasty decisions that they later regret.

Finding a Middle Path: Cultural Sensitivity in Education

The Indian education system needs to acknowledge the benefits of the European model of education while ensuring that cultural sensitivity is maintained. Instead of blindly adopting Western ideas, schools must create a structured approach where:

Sex education is given with moral guidance, emphasising emotional responsibility, cultural values, and respect for personal and family honour.
Students are taught the balance between personal freedom and social responsibility, ensuring they make informed and disciplined choices.
Parents are involved in open yet value-based discussions to help young individuals navigate adolescence responsibly.
The education system promotes modern thinking without dismantling the core ethics and traditions that define Indian culture.

Conclusion

While the European education system has many positive aspects, its openness in relationships and unrestricted personal freedom can be problematic in the Indian setting. The absence of structured guidance and the clash between traditional Indian values and Western ideals often lead to confusion, family conflicts, and even social shame. The way forward is not to reject modern ideas but to adapt them in a way that respects cultural norms and maintains emotional, moral, and social stability for students growing up in Indian society.

Case Study: The Indian Student Abroad

A student from India who studied in Finland appreciated their education model, but struggled with social relationships. He said, “In India, relationships are built on emotions and family. In Europe, intimacy is casual. I couldn’t adjust.”

This highlights the cultural gap and the need for an education model that balances:

Progressive learning (like in Europe)
Emotional and ethical grounding (as per Indian values)

The Role of Educators: Mental Counselling & Emotional Support

As educators, we must recognise that academic success alone is not enough. Students need emotional intelligence, moral guidance, and mental health support.

What Can We Do?

Encourage parent-child bonding – Parents must prioritise emotional care over just grades.
incorporate value-based education – Schools should include ethics, relationships, and self-awareness as part of the curriculum.
Offer professional counselling – Every school should have mental health professionals to help students navigate emotional challenges.
Balance modern education with cultural values – Learning should be scientific yet culturally respectful.
Address societal influences – Schools should monitor peer influences and provide a safe, structured environment.

Conclusion: Success with a Soul

A successful student is not just one who scores well but one who is mentally, emotionally, and socially stable. While we admire European education for its methods, we must also preserve the emotional and cultural depth of Indian society.

As educators, our mission should be to create balanced individuals—intelligent, compassionate, and emotionally aware. The future of our society depends not just on how well our students perform, but on how well they live as human beings. Success with a Soul

Success is often measured by academic excellence, financial stability, and career growth. However, true success goes beyond numbers and achievements—it lies in emotional well-being, strong values, and meaningful relationships.

Today’s education system focuses heavily on performance but neglects mental health, ethics, and emotional intelligence. Many high achievers struggle with isolation, stress, and a lack of purpose. Success without emotional grounding leads to emptiness, while knowledge without values can be dangerous.

To create truly successful individuals, we must balance intelligence with empathy, ambition with ethics, and personal achievements with social responsibility. Educators should prioritise life skills and emotional resilience, parents should focus on emotional bonding, and society should redefine success to include happiness and integrity. Ultimately, success is not just about what we achieve but who we become. A society that nurtures not just intelligent minds but also compassionate hearts and strong characters is one that truly thrives.

A Teacher’s Reflection

I’ve seen countless students who topped exams but trembled inside when life tested them differently. Their stories are real, their pain invisible, and their silence loud. As educators, parents, and mentors, our role is not just to produce achievers but to protect the human inside the achiever. The real story of education is not found in report cards—it’s written in the hearts of students who are struggling to stay emotionally alive in a world obsessed with success.

. . .

References:

Discus