In the past year, the extensive use of Chinese Manja or hazardous nylon kite string has resulted in a series of accidents claiming at least six lives and causing multiple injuries in different parts of Uttar Pradesh. Till the middle of the month February this year, 11 such incidents were reported, out of which one person died, and 10 people were injured. Once upon a time, the so-called Chinese manja was manufactured in China and exported to India. But of late, most “Chinese manja” sold in India is manufactured locally. The label “Chinese”, however, remains in vogue as early versions or key raw materials like synthetic polymers and polypropylene were imported from China, or the technology was associated with Chinese manufacturing.1 Chinese manja is quite distinct from traditional kite strings in use for decades, which are typically made from cotton thread coated with natural adhesives such as rice glue or tree gum, along with mild abrasives like powdered glass or alum. These strings, prepared manually by skilled workers, are considered relatively safer as they tend to snap under stress. On the contrary, the Chinese manja is made from synthetic materials such as nylon or plastic monofilament and often coated with finely ground glass, metal dust or other sharp abrasives. Such a string is definitely stronger, sharper and far more dangerous. Moreover, unlike cotton strings, synthetic manja does not snap easily. It can remain stretched across roads and open spaces for a long time, posing a serious risk to the public. This kind of synthetic kite string is nearly invisible and can prove to be fatal for unsuspecting commuters, particularly those riding two-wheelers.2
Chinese manja or synthetic kite string is not only dangerous to humans but is equally dangerous to birds. In the city of Hyderabad, Telangana, 26 birds were rescued on Makar Sankranti day alone this year, of which five died, and four were released on the spot. The remaining 17 were shifted to the shelter with injuries. Species falling victim to the manja include rivertern, green bee eater, black-headed ibis, shikra, peafowl, black kite, and barn owl, to name a few. According to Soudharm Bhandari from Greater Hyderabad Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, “Chinese manja was not the culprit in all cases. Of all the cases, 10 were caused by glass-coated cotton thread manja while one was caused by normal cotton thread, which caught the bird but did not cause injuries.”3
The Reason Behind the Use of Chinese Manja.
Undoubtedly, kite- flying is a popular sport in India, which often takes the shape of a kite-flying contest where the ability to cut the rival's kite becomes the focal point. In this pursuit, a stronger and sharper string offers a better advantage to cut other people's flying kites easily. Chinese manja, or synthetic manja, is cheaper than the traditional manja. Its low cost and effectiveness have led to its widespread use despite the ban imposed by several States. Thus, the cheaper nylon or plastic string becomes lethal when it is stretched across streets or ‘tangled’ at neck level. “The competitive practice of ‘tangling’ gives the pastime a lethal edge as rooftop participants attempt to cut the kites of others, often prioritising victory over safety.”4
The plastic-based thread is manufactured in cities like Ahmedabad and Bengaluru, and it is sold openly through online platforms. A spindle of traditional cotton string costs between Rs. 2,500 and Rs. 3,500, while the banned plastic string is available online for as meagre an amount as Rs. 250 to Rs. 600 per spindle, making it easily accessible despite legal restrictions.5
In all such cases, the police have invoked the following Sections of the relevant Acts:
Bhartiya Nyay Sanhita, 2023
Environmental Protection Act, 1986
Note: In all reported cases, an FIR was filed, but no further progress was made by the police. Even the culprits have not been identified.
High Courts across the country have expressed serious concern over the 'deadly effects’ of ‘Chinese manjha’ (nylon kite strings) and directed the respective state authorities to impose a complete ban on its manufacturing and sale.16
In the U.P., the situation is more drastic, and the use of Chinese manjha seems to be unstoppable despite the complete ban on it by the State government. Recently, the Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath has clearly stated that deaths caused by the sharp synthetic thread should be treated on par with murder. He said, “Strict legal action will be taken against those responsible in such cases.” However, no effective preventive action has yet been taken to control the online shopping of Chinese manjha or synthetic nylon string by the e-commerce companies.21
For decades, kite flying has been a popular sport among the masses. People enjoy this game at a few specific festivals and occasions. This sport is linked with mental and manual skill, in which cutting the string of others' kites flying high in the sky matters most. It gives immense joy to the victor whose kite remains in the realm of the open sky. But of late, kite fliers have developed the habit of winning by hook or crook. For this, they employ dangerous threads such as the Chinese manjha and synthetic nylon strings to cut the flying kites of others. These strings are almost visible to the wayfarers on the road. It entangles mainly the upper parts of the body, cutting the throat or bruising the parts of the face and head, often resulting in death or serious injuries to the victim. Now, e-commerce has come to the rescue of the buyers, and unfortunately, no effective checks can be enforced by the respective governments. Since the number of casualties is gradually increasing, there is an urgent need to control the ill-conceived and dangerous practice of using Chinese manjha and other synthetic nylon strings. Safeguarding the lives of people is the primary duty of the State, and that should be ensured at all costs. Though the government has banned its use, the implementation of government orders leaves much to be desired. Different High Courts of the country have also issued appropriate orders to effectively control the problem. Only sufficient willpower is required by the official machinery. The laws should be enforced strictly, and the culprits should be punished without showing any mercy. It is high time to take stringent measures to save the lives of innocent people who travel on roads without anticipating any trouble of such a dangerous nature.
Reference