A City on the Move

In the bustling heart of Mumbai, local trains are the lifeblood of the city, weaving through the urban landscape like arteries. Every day, millions of Mumbaikars rely on these trains to get to work, school, and home. Yet, amid the daily grind, a grim reality unfolds. The crowded compartments, the rush-hour frenzy—these mundane scenes can turn fatal in an instant. Let’s delve into the harrowing statistics and stories behind the train fatalities that have gripped the city.

The Tragic Tale of K R Savla

K.R.Savla, a 37-year-old garment salesman, embarked on his usual commute to Dadar cloth market. But on June 6, tragedy struck. Amid the crush of passengers, he slipped from the footboard between Diva and Mumbra stations. As the train curved, his grip loosened, and he plummeted onto the tracks. His life was extinguished in that heart-stopping moment, leaving behind a grieving family. The impact of these tragedies extends beyond numbers. Families lose their main breadwinners, reduced to garlanded photographs.

Alarming Statistics

Data from the Sunday Mirror paints a grim picture: 250 lives were lost due to falls from trains in Mumbai during the first five months of 2024. An additional 562 were injured. While this figure is slightly lower than the 271 fatalities recorded during the same period last year, it remains deeply concerning. In 2023, a total of 2,590 individuals lost their lives on Mumbai's suburban railway tracks, averaging seven deaths per day. The majority of these fatalities resulted from unauthorized track crossings and falling off running trains. These statistics paint a stark picture of the risks faced by commuters. They are not just numbers; they represent real lives and shattered families.

The Danger Zones

Certain stretches witness a higher incidence of fatal falls. Along the nine-kilometre distance between Thane and Diva, 23 travellers met their demise this year. Similar perilous spots exist around Kalyan, Kurla, Borivali, and Vasai. The Government Railway Police (GRP) reported the highest number of deaths from train falls in Kalyan, with 51 cases, followed by Kurla with 30 cases and Thane with 23 cases.

A Young Survivor’s Tale

Farhan Ansari, a 12-year-old, innocently embarked on a joyride with friends. But fate intervened between Bandra and Mahim stations. He slipped off the train, and a GRP constable heroically rescued him. Yet, Farhan’s left leg had to be amputated. Now confined to Shahu Nagar, he reflects on his once cheerful life and asks, "Will I survive?" His father, Kamaru Ansari, reflects on the changes: "Things are not the same anymore."

Unraveling the Causes of Train Fall Fatalities

What causes these tragic incidents? Are overcrowded trains and hurried passengers the only culprits, or is there more to the story? Is the infrastructure failing to keep up with the city's rapid growth? Are safety measures adequate, or do they need a significant overhaul? Commuters, railway officials, and safety advocates all have their perspectives. 

One daily commuter shares, "Every day feels like a gamble. You never know if you'll reach your destination safely." A railway official adds, "We are doing our best, but the sheer volume of passengers makes it challenging to ensure everyone's safety."

The train fall fatalities in Mumbai result from a combination of factors. Here are the major causes:

1. Overcrowding:

Mumbai’s local trains are notorious for their overcrowded compartments during peak hours. Passengers often hang precariously from footboards, making them vulnerable to falls.

The Daily Crush: A sea of humanity, crammed into train compartments. Elbows jostle, bags collide, and personal space evaporates. Mumbai’s local trains transform into a chaotic battleground during rush hours. But what happens when the battle spills onto the footboards? The footboard—a precarious perch—beckons the daring. Commuters cling to it, defying gravity and common sense. Their fingers grip the metal edge, knuckles white, as the train hurtles forward. Balancing on the footboard is an art form. Feet planted firmly, bodies swaying with the rhythm of the tracks, passengers become tightrope walkers. They exchange knowing glances, acknowledging their shared vulnerability. One wrong move, and they plummet into the abyss.

The Perils of Overcrowding: Overcrowding exacerbates the danger. When the train doors refuse to close, bodies spill out. The footboard becomes an extension of the compartment—an overflow zone. Passengers dangle, half in, half out, their lives hanging by a thread. Footboard etiquette emerges—a silent pact among travellers. Eyes meet, signaling cooperation. Strangers brace each other, preventing falls. A seasoned commuter offers a reassuring nod to a novice. It’s survival, camaraderie, and defiance rolled into one.

The Price of Desperation: Why do they risk it? For some, it’s a calculated risk; for others, a desperate necessity. It’s the only way to reach work on time. For some others, poverty leaves no choice. They cling to the footboard, their dreams and fears merging with the clatter of wheels. The city’s heartbeat pulses through their fingertips.

A Call for Change: As Mumbai grapples with this daily drama, safety measures remain elusive. The footboard warriors persist, their stories etched into the city’s fabric. Perhaps someday, the lifeline will be safer—a place where passengers ride within compartments, not on the edge of existence.

Mumbai’s overcrowded trains—where lives intersect, balance teeters, and resilience prevails—reveal both the city’s chaos and its indomitable spirit.

2. Slippery Surfaces:

Footboards and steps—those humble pathways we often take for granted—can turn treacherous when wet, icy, or grimy. Whether you’re navigating a crowded train or climbing outdoor stairs, a slip can have dire consequences. A momentary loss of balance can lead to a fatal fall. What makes footboards and steps so slippery? Rain, dew, sweat, and even moss or algae buildup can transform them into potential hazards. Add autumn leaves or frosty weather, and the problem compounds.

False Economies: Before we dive into solutions, let’s debunk some ineffective approaches:

• Pressure Washing: It’s a temporary fix.
• Wood Cleaners: They don’t provide lasting results.
• Gritted Paint or Tape: These need frequent reapplication.

Cost-Effective Solutions: Enter Safe Tread—a hero in the battle against slippery steps. Their anti-slip products are made from durable GRP (glass-reinforced plastic) and come with a 10-year guarantee.

Installation Tips:

• Use sturdy handrails on both sides.
• Ensure adequate lighting.
• Keep steps clear of debris.

Choose the right fixing method for installation.

Remember, safety trumps aesthetics. Let’s make footboards and steps safer—one sure step at a time!

3. Negligence:

Commuters sometimes lean too far out of moving trains, misjudge gaps, or disregard safety precautions. These lapses can prove deadly.

The Lean of No Return: A crowded local train hurtling through the city with commuters pressed against each other, lean out—perhaps to catch a breeze or glimpse the world outside. But that lean, innocent at first, can lead to tragedy. A slip, a misjudgment, and suddenly, life hangs in the balance.

The Gap Gambit: Platforms and trains play a game of inches. Yet, some commuters treat the gap between them as a mere inconvenience. They step over it, teetering on the edge. But what if the gap swallows them whole? Negligence turns a routine commute into a life-altering event.

Disregarding Safety Precautions: Signs scream “Do Not Lean Out!” Yet, some passengers ignore them. They dangle bags, peer out, and risk everything. The train’s rhythm lulls them into complacency.

The Cost of a Second’s Lapse: A momentary lapse—leaning too far, misjudging the gap—can cost a life. Families lose income earners, dreams shatter, and the city mourns. Negligence, seemingly innocuous, leaves scars deeper than the tracks themselves.

A Call to Vigilance: Let’s heed the warnings. Let’s respect the gap, honour safety precautions, and protect lives. Because in Mumbai’s crowded trains, negligence isn’t just a lapse—it’s a gamble with existence.

4. Lack of Awareness:

Many passengers remain unaware of the risks associated with travelling on footboards. Ignorance about safety guidelines contributes to accidents.

The Unseen Danger: Footboards, those narrow ledges between life and tracks are both a necessity and a peril. Yet, many commuters remain blissfully unaware of the risks they pose. Ignorance isn’t bliss.

The Silent Warnings: Despite the precautionary signs, commuters continue to ignore them. They hang bags, stare into the abyss, and gamble everything. The rhythmic clatter of wheels soothes them, but the tracks don’t care—they’re unforgiving.

A Call to Awareness: Let’s educate fellow travellers. Protecting lives is crucial, as negligence on Mumbai's trains isn't merely a mistake but risking life itself.

5. Inadequate Infrastructure:

Insufficient handrails, poorly maintained footboards, and gaps between platforms and trains exacerbate the danger.

Handrails, Missing in Action: Ever noticed the scarcity of handrails? They’re like elusive companions, vanishing just when you need them most. Commuters struggle to find secure grips, especially during peak hours. Whether it’s a crowded local train or a deserted platform, gripping a nonexistent handrail feels like balancing on a tightrope. We need sturdy handholds to prevent slips and falls.

Hazardous Footboards: Footboards are essential for boarding and alighting from trains, yet their maintenance often falls short. Cracks, slippery surfaces, and missing footholds make these areas hazardous. Commuters are forced to navigate these unsafe conditions, increasing the risk of accidents. Rain, sweat, and grime turn footboards into treacherous slopes. Imagine clinging to a slippery edge, hoping for stability. It’s a silent battle against gravity—one misstep away from disaster. Regular maintenance and anti-slip measures are crucial.

Mind the Void: Perhaps the most alarming issue is the significant gaps that exist between platforms and trains. These gaps, sometimes wide enough to trap belongings or even endanger limbs, are a constant concern. Despite warnings, accidents resulting from these gaps are not uncommon, highlighting a critical need for better infrastructure planning and maintenance.

The Urgent Call for Resilience: We need stronger public-private partnerships, project finance, and risk management. It's time for concerted efforts to prioritize infrastructure upgrades and uphold passenger safety in our railway systems. Let’s bridge the infrastructure gap, let’s make footboards safer. Because safety isn’t a luxury—it’s the thin line between life and lapses. 

6. Sudden Braking or Acceleration:

Train journeys are akin to a roller coaster ride, with sudden changes in speed causing passengers to sway and stumble. When trains suddenly brake or accelerate, passengers lose their balance. The crush of bodies during these moments increases the risk of falls.

The Unexpected Jolt: Sudden braking or acceleration catches passengers off guard disrupting their balance. This can be particularly challenging to standing passengers who rely on stability to navigate crowded compartments.

The Risk of Falls: During these abrupt manoeuvres, passengers jostle against each other, creating a chaotic environment where falls become more likely. This scenario is exacerbated in densely packed rush-hour trains. Without proper handholds or secure footing, passengers may lose their balance and sustain injuries. The force exerted during these moments can lead to muscle pulls, sprains, and even fractures.

Safety Measures: To mitigate these risks, there is a critical need for:

• Enhanced Stability Features: Installing more handrails and securing footholds can provide passengers with better stability during sudden movements.
• Communication and Alerts: Clear announcements and visual alerts can prepare passengers for upcoming speed changes, allowing them to brace themselves.
• Infrastructure Upgrades: Continuous maintenance of tracks and trains to minimize sudden braking or acceleration incidents.
• Train Design: Modernizing train interiors to include more safety features, such as padded surfaces and anti-slip flooring, can reduce the impact of falls.
• Passenger Education: Teaching passengers about safe travel practices, such as holding onto handrails and avoiding movement during stops and starts, can help minimize risks.

7. Emergency Alighting: 

Passengers often jump off moving trains during emergencies, leading to severe injuries or fatalities.

The Urgent Exit: When chaos erupts—fire, smoke, or a sudden threat—passengers face a split-second decision: stay or leap. Emergency alighting becomes a desperate escape route. This impulsive action is often driven by fear or a sense of urgency to escape potential danger.

Severe Injuries and Fatalities: Jumping off a moving train is extremely hazardous and can result in severe injuries or fatalities. Passengers risk falling onto the tracks, colliding with structures along the platform, or being struck by the train itself.

Legal and Operational Implications: Aside from the immediate physical risks, emergency alighting can have legal consequences for both passengers and railway operators. It disrupts train operations and poses challenges for emergency responders who must attend to injured passengers and secure the area.

Promoting Safer Practices: To mitigate the risks associated with emergency alighting, it is crucial to educate passengers on emergency procedures and stress the importance of following safety protocols during crises. Rail operators, stations, and commuters—let’s prepare. Clear exit paths and minimize panic.

Efforts to address these issues—through awareness campaigns, infrastructure improvements, and stricter enforcement—are crucial to reducing train fall fatalities. 

Commuter Safety Tips for Train Journeys

Commuters can take several safety measures to reduce the risk of train fall fatalities:

1. Stay Inside the Compartment: Avoid hanging from footboards or leaning out of moving trains. Move away from the doors and deeper into the train. Always stay inside the designated area.
2. Hold the Handrails: When standing near the doors, hold onto the handrails firmly. This provides stability during sudden movements.
3. Mind the Gap: While boarding or alighting, be cautious of the gap between the platform and the train. Step carefully.
4. Avoid Rushing: During crowded rush hours, it’s tempting to hurry. However, rushing increases the chances of accidents. Maintain a steady pace.
5. Be Aware of Emergency Exits: Familiarize yourself with emergency exits and procedures. In case of an emergency, follow instructions from railway staff.
6. Report Hazardous Conditions: If you notice broken handrails, slippery surfaces, or other safety hazards, report them promptly to railway authorities.
7. Emergency Alighting: Never jump off a moving train unless it’s an emergency.

Step Smart, Stay Safe! Remember, safety is everyone’s responsibility. Let’s make our train journeys safer for all!

Enhancing Railway Infrastructure

Our railway, the arteries of connectivity, deserves robust safety infrastructure. Improving safety infrastructure for railways is crucial to prevent accidents and protect passengers. Let’s explore strategies to fortify our tracks, bridges, and systems, ensuring safer journeys for all.

1. Investment in Technology:

Digital Railway: Adopt digital solutions to improve train control, signalling, and communication systems.

Traffic Management: Use technology to reduce delays and optimize train movements.

Augmented Reality: Explore AR applications for maintenance and safety inspections.

2. Track and Bridge Upgrades:

• Regularly inspect and maintain tracks and bridges to preventaccidents due to structural issues.
• Rehabilitate ageing infrastructure to improve safety and reliability.

3. Modern Signaling Systems:

• Replace outdated signalling with modern, automated systems.
• These systems enhance train control, reduce delays, and prevent collisions.

4. Grade Crossing Elimination:

• Identify and eliminate dangerous highway-rail grade crossings.
• Install barriers, warning signs, and signals to prevent collisions.

5. Safety Training Programs:

• Train railway employees rigorously on safety protocols.
• Educate passengers about safe behaviour near tracks and platforms.

6. Emergency Response Preparedness:

• Equip stations and trains with emergency equipment.
• Train staff to handle emergencies effectively.

7. Risk Assessment and Mitigation:

• Analyze risks associated with specific routes and take preventive measures.
• Address vulnerable areas prone to accidents.

8. Collaboration with Stakeholders:

• Work closely with government agencies, rail operators, and local communities.
• Engage in transparent communication about safety initiatives.

9. Funding Allocation:

• Ensure adequate funding for safety enhancements during periodic reviews.
• Prioritize safety-related projects.

10. Research and Innovation:

• Explore alternative gauging methodologies and sustainable materials.
• Invest in research to enhance safety practices.

By implementing these measures, authorities can create a safer railway system for passengers and freight alike.

Indian Railways’ Safety Triumphs

Indian Railways has made significant strides in enhancing safety through various initiatives. Here are some success stories:

1. Rashtriya Rail Sanrakshan Kosh (RRSK):

• Launched in 2017, RRSK aims to replace, renew, and upgrade safety assets across the railway network.
• RRSK has allocated ₹1.08 lakh crore from 2017 to 2022, focusing on infrastructure improvements and accident prevention.

2. Kavach: Indigenous Train Protection System:

• Kavach, an Automatic Train Protection (ATP) system, prevents collisions by automatically applying brakes if drivers fail to do so.
• Implemented across 1,465 Route Kilometers (RKMs), Kavach improves safety and response time.

3. Electronic Interlocking Systems:

• Over 6,586 stations in India now have Electronic Interlocking (EI) systems.
• These systems provide secure interlocking of level crossing gates, thereby reducing accidents.

4. Vigilance Control Devices (VCDs):

• All trains are equipped with VCDs to monitor pilot alertness throughout the journey.
• GPS-enabled fog protection devices aid drivers in low visibility conditions.

5. Track Recording Cars:

• These cars check track fitness and facilitate immediate repairs, ensuring safety.
• Ultrasonic trials promptly detect track defects, preventing accidents.

6. Gajraj System:

• Train collisions with elephants pose a grave threat to both wildlife and passengers.
• The Northeast Frontier Railway (NFR) introduced the AI-driven Gajraj System.
• Infrared sensors detect elephants near tracks. Train drivers receive real-time alerts to slow down or stop. 
• Elephant fatalities due to train collisions reduced significantly.

7. Mission Zero Accident:

This initiative aims to eliminate accidents by addressing issues such as unmanned level crossings, derailments, and collisions.

8. Safety Information Management System (SIMS):

• SIMS manages and processes information related to train accidents that occur in Indian Railways.
• It enables the anonymous and confidential reporting of hazards or risks related to railway safety directly to the Chief Safety Officer.

These initiatives demonstrate Indian Railways’ commitment to passenger safety and efficient operations.

Tackling Overcrowding in Morning Trains

Morning trains—the frenetic pulse of urban life—often resemble sardine cans hurtling through tunnels. As commuters jostle for space, it’s clear that overcrowding is a pressing issue. But fear not! Let’s explore creative solutions that can ease the squeeze and make those early rides more bearable.

1. Flexible Work Hours: The Game-Change

Proposal: Corporates and offices can encourage staggered work timings. Imagine if rush hour extended from 7 a.m. to 11 a.m. instead of the usual 8 a.m. to 9 a.m.

Spread the Load: By allowing employees to start their workday at different times, we reduce the peak-hour crush.

Productivity Boost: Early birds and night owls alike can optimize their productivity.

Less Stress: No more frantic dashes to catch that elusive 8:15 train!

2. Designing Smarter Trains: Beyond Sardine Cans

Folding Seats: Imagine seats that fold up during peak hours, creating the standing room. Efficient, right?

Double-Decker Trains: Why not stack passengers like Tetris blocks? Double-decker carriages could double capacity.

Wider Standing Spaces: Let’s rethink those narrow aisles. Wider spaces mean fewer elbows in your ribs.

3. Hotspot Awareness: Navigating the Chaos

Major Interchange Stations: These are the epicentres of chaos. Avoid them during peak hours.

Alternate Routes: Study the map. Sometimes a slightly longer route means a less crowded journey.

4. Tech-Savvy Solutions: Apps and Alerts

Crowd Prediction Apps: Get real-time information on crowded trains and adjust train schedules accordingly.

Alerts for Empty Trains: Imagine an app whispering, “Psst! The next train is blissfully empty.”

5. Short Turning Pattern:

What Is It?: Short turning involves terminating a train before its final destination and turning it back to serve another route.

How It Helps: By short-turning specific trains during peak hours, we can redistribute passenger loads and alleviate overcrowding in critical areas.

For example: Shanghai Metro Line 2 successfully implemented a short turning between Beixinjing and Longyang Road, which eased congestion.

Overcrowding isn’t invincible. With a dash of creativity, a sprinkle of flexibility, and a pinch of tech magic, we can transform our morning commute from chaos to comfort.

Balancing Comfort and Commute

Mumbai’s local trains carry millions of passengers daily. Among them, the debate rages: AC trains or regular ones? Let’s dive into this heated discussion, exploring the pros, cons, and the crowded reality that commuters face.

1. The Cool Comfort of AC Trains

The Arrival: In 2017, Mumbai welcomed its first AC local train—a sleek, air-conditioned marvel. Automatic doors, fire safety systems, and plush seats made it an instant hit.

Summer Saviors: When the sun scorches, AC trains offer respite. No more sweat-soaked shirts or wilting commuters.

Gradual Expansion: Western Railway now boasts 96 AC trains, easing the summer grind.

2. The Price of Coolness

Affordability Gap: AC tickets cost more. Not everyone’s wallet can handle the chill.

Non-AC Overcrowding: As AC trains replace regular ones, the latter bears the brunt. Overcrowding surges and tempers flare.

Plea: “Make all trains AC, but keep general class fares unchanged,” suggests a frustrated commuter.

3. The Battle of Tradition vs. Comfort

The Divide: New commuters crave AC luxury even during peak hours. Veterans cling to their familiar non-AC rides.

Tug of War: Western Railway’s plan to introduce more AC services sparks controversy. Old Habits Die Hard.

4. Finding the Middle Track

Balancing Act: Can we blend comfort and accessibility? Separate classes, perhaps?

Inclusive Solutions: Let’s innovate—more AC trains, but affordable options for all.

Safety First: Regardless of AC or not, safety remains paramount.

As Mumbai’s trains chug forward, we grapple with choices. AC or regular? Tradition or modernity? Maybe it’s time for a hybrid—a train that cools our bodies without overheating our wallets. 

Navigating Challenges in Passenger Awareness Campaigns

In the world of railways, safety awareness campaigns are our guiding beacons. But like any journey, they encounter twists and turns. Let’s explore the challenges these campaigns face and how we can keep the safety torch burning.

1. Information Overload:

Issue: Bombarding passengers with too much information can lead to apathy.

Solution: Focus on key safety points and repeat them consistently. Messages must be concise and relevant.

2. Language and Literacy:

Issue: Diverse language backgrounds and literacy levels make communication tricky.

Solution: Use visual cues, symbols, and multilingual posters to convey safety messages.

3. Commuter Apathy:

Issue: Passengers often ignore safety announcements due to routine or distractions.

Solution: Engage creatively—videos, interactive displays, or contests—to grab attention. Unexpected safety reminders grab attention.

4. Skepticism and Trust:

Issue: Passengers may doubt the campaign's sincerity or effectiveness.

Solution: Build trust through transparency and real-world success stories.

5. Consistency and Sustainability:

Issue: Campaigns lose impact if not sustained over time.

Solution: Integrate safety messages into daily routines and station environments.

Awareness campaigns thrive when tailored to passengers’ needs and delivered consistently. By navigating these challenges, we ensure that every passenger becomes a safety advocate.

Seeking Solutions

Rail activists point to the underutilization of infrastructure and inadequate services to match the growing commuter density. As Mumbai’s lifeline, the local trains demand urgent attention. Safety measures, awareness campaigns, and improved infrastructure are critical to prevent more tragedies.

A Call for Change

The distressing figures and personal stories underscore the urgent need for action. Improved safety measures, better infrastructure, and increased public awareness are crucial steps toward preventing these tragic incidents. As the city continues to grow and evolve, ensuring the safety of its residents must remain a top priority.

Looking Forward

As we dig deep into the alarming data and narratives surrounding the train fatalities that have plagued Mumbai, it's evident that change is essential. How can we make Mumbai's lifeblood safer for everyone? How can we transform these daily journeys from a game of chance to a guaranteed safe passage? Mumbai's deadly commute demands our attention, and the time for action is now.

Navigating Safely Together

Mumbai’s local trains remain a lifeline, but they also pose a daily gamble. As we mourn the fallen, urgent safety measures must be implemented to prevent further loss of life. The city’s trains must carry passengers safely, not as cattle but as lives intertwined with hope and survival.

As the sun rises over Mumbai’s tracks, it casts shadows—both literal and metaphorical. The lives lost, and the echoes of footsteps silenced are not mere statistics. They are stories etched into the steel and stone, whispered by the wind. Perhaps someday, the lifeline will be safer—a place where passengers ride within compartments, not on the edge of existence.

But let us not linger in sorrow. Let us rise like the morning mist, fueled by resolve. For every tragedy, there are questions waiting to be answered: Can we weave safety into our daily fabric? Can we hold the railings not just for balance, but for life? Can we transform crowded platforms into vigilant communities?

Safety isn’t a solitary journey—it’s a collective track we tread. Let’s mind the gap, heed the warnings, and protect one another. Let us honour those who fell by standing firm, reporting hazards, by being the guardians of our rails. And as the trains pull away, let us whisper to the wind: “Not one more. Not on our watch.

Reference:

• www.hindustantimes.com
• www.timesofindia.com
• https://etrr.springeropen.com
• www.railway-technology.com
• www.railwaynews.com
• www.indianrilways.gov.in
• www.safety.indianrail.gov.in
• www.financialexpress.com

.    .    .