Chasing Sarkari Jobs : Indian Youth Trapped in the Government Job Rat Race

In the heart of India's educational landscape lies a booming test-preparation industry, a phenomenon that reveals much more than just academic ambition. It speaks volumes about the country’s demographic aspirations, regional inequalities, and the shrinking promise of stable employment.

Regional Hubs of Competitive Coaching

Across Northern India, certain cities have emerged as epicentres of competitive exam preparation. Delhi, with its extensive coaching centres in areas like Mukherji Nagar, Rajendra Nagar, and Munirka, continues to be a magnet for job seekers. Not far behind are cities like Allahabad—drawing hopefuls from eastern Uttar Pradesh—and Rajasthan's Jaipur and Jodhpur, where coaching hubs flourish. Even smaller cities such as Sikar in Rajasthan have carved a niche as affordable alternatives for those unable to bear the high cost of living in larger cities.

These cities have become known to have the adoption of rigorous study schedules, coaching institutions, and thousands of rented rooms occupied by young aspirants chasing the vague dream of a secure government job.

Neighbourhoods of Silent Struggle

Certain localities within these cities have evolved into concentrated zones of India’s “educated unemployed.” Places like Vivek Vihar in Jaipur, Katra and Baghada in Allahabad, and the aforementioned neighbourhoods in Delhi are home to young individuals who have completed their formal education but are yet to secure employment. They spend their days studying all day, attending coaching classes, and taking mock tests, all in hopes of cracking competitive exams.

This community represents what has long been advertised as India’s demographic dividend, where a vast pool of young, educated citizens is ready to contribute to the workforce. However, their prolonged state of preparation with no guaranteed outcome reflects a more miserable picture.

A Shrinking Window of Opportunity

The challenge, however, runs deeper than just the competition. The number of secure, formal-sector jobs, particularly in the government, is not keeping pace with the rising number of aspirants. Former Reserve Bank of India Governor Raghuram Rajan highlighted this troubling imbalance when he pointed out that 25 million young people had applied for just 90,000 low-level jobs in the Indian Railways.

This staggering statistic underscores a critical reality that economic growth has not translated into proportional job creation. While India’s GDP may continue to rise, the absence of adequate employment opportunities risks turning the country's youthful energy into frustration and disillusionment.

Aspirations delayed or denied

The test preparation industry thrives on the dreams of millions. But beneath the surface of this thriving sector is a complex web of limited job prospects, intense competition, and unfulfilled potential. As thousands of India’s youth dedicate the major years of their lives to preparing for uncertain futures, the country faces a pressing question: Can it convert its demographic promise into a real economic advantage?

Why Are Government Jobs So Popular Among Indian Youth?

It’s a question that’s often asked: Why do so many young Indian people prefer government jobs over private sector opportunities or entrepreneurship? The answer may seem simple at first glance, i.e. benefits. Government jobs are known for:

Job security
High starting salaries
Medical benefits
Tuition support for children
Travel and housing allowances
Respect and recognition in society
Lower workloads in some departments
Comfortable work environments with fewer daily challenges

These advantages are widely talked about and praised in our society. Many students and job seekers accept them as facts without digging deeper. But beneath this admiration lies a deeper issue that many aspirants don’t truly understand their career goals or ambitions. They chase a government job because everyone else around them is doing the same.

A Middle-Class Aspiration

For many aspirants from middle-class or financially weaker families, a government job is the ultimate dream. Exams like SSC, Banking, Railways, UPSC, and Defence Services become the centre of their lives. In any given locality across India, you’ll find numerous youths dedicating years to this dream of a “Sarkari Naukri”.

Job Security: The Most Desired Benefit

One of the strongest reasons behind this craze is job security. In contrast to the private sector, where layoffs and sudden terminations are common, government jobs offer long-term stability. People feel safer knowing their jobs are secure even during economic downturns. This sense of safety discourages many young Indians from exploring riskier paths like starting a business or becoming entrepreneurs. Comfort becomes more attractive than challenge.

Social Respect and Power

From a young age, Indian children are influenced by family and society to admire government officers. Parents often highlight the status and respect that come with positions of power. Uniforms, stars, and the ability to command attention become symbols of success. Stories of bribery and influence, though concerning, are also discussed casually by adding to the idea that a government job provides unmatched authority and lifestyle.

The Harsh Reality Behind the Dream

While all of these benefits are real, what’s rarely talked about is the hard truth of how incredibly difficult it is to get a government job. The competition is fierce. For instance, in the SSC exams, over 20 lakh candidates apply, and about 9 lakh take the exam, but only 5,000 vacancies are available. For Railway NTPC and Group D, 2.5 crore applicants compete for 35,000–1,00,000 seats. These numbers clearly show how aspirants are caught in a rat race. Most of them enter this race not because of personal ambition, but because of pressure from family, friends, YouTube videos, and social media promotions.

Coaching Centres: Selling Dreams, Not Reality

Many coaching institutes play a key role in feeding this craze. They use marketing tricks like putting up posters of successful students with slogans like “You could be next.” These ads build false hope and often manipulate the emotions of students and their parents. What they don’t reveal is the actual success rate of their coaching. How many students joined? How many passed? That information is rarely shared. Their real goal is simple: to earn money from aspirants, not necessarily to guide them towards success. Sadly, many of these coaching centre owners enjoy luxurious lifestyles that have been funded by the hard-earned money of students' parents, while students struggle without proper guidance or career clarity.

In the majority of cases, after exams are over then these coaching institutes don’t even bother to contact students because they have already taken fees in advance, and many deserving students are already left behind in the race. These coaching institutes only contact successful students and even buy ranks as well for better marketing and establishing a credible coaching institute image. They also give a commission to those students who have advertised their courses independently in their networks.

The Real Solution: Career Counselling

So what’s the way out? The answer lies in career counselling. Every student should consult a career counsellor before diving into the competitive exam world. Coaching institutes should offer this service as part of their duty. But if they don’t, then it becomes the responsibility of parents and students themselves. It’s time to move past outdated thinking. Blaming students for being lazy or blaming the government for low vacancies doesn’t help. We must shift the focus to career planning, realistic goals, and self-awareness.

Loving a government job isn’t wrong, but only if you’re truly passionate about it. If you have the patience, dedication, and consistent effort needed to crack these exams, go for it. But don’t let societal pressure or smart marketing fool you. Take charge of your future. Choose what’s right for you, not just what looks good to others.

The Enduring Attraction of Government Jobs: A Deeper Look

The pursuit of a government job remains a deeply ingrained aspiration for many young people in India. While often celebrated, this phenomenon is rooted in a complex interplay of generational influence, perceived stability, and an evolving job market. This isn't just a trend; it's a societal pattern worth exploring in detail.

The Weight of Generational Conditioning

From an early age, many students are subtly, and sometimes overtly, steered towards government service as the epitome of a successful career. This generational conditioning often begins during their foundational academic years, instilling the idea that a government job is the "ideal job." It's a narrative passed down through families and communities, often overshadowing individual interests or aptitudes. How many of us have been advised to appear for government job exams, regardless of our true passions? This ingrained belief system undoubtedly plays a significant role in shaping career choices even before a student fully understands the broader professional landscape.

Stability, Security, and the Corporate Contrast

While scrolling through memes about corporate life can be amusing, the harsh reality for many working in the private sector often paints a stark contrast to the perceived benefits of government employment. Long working hours, job instability, and a potentially toxic work culture are common complaints in many private industries. For those seeking an escape from this demanding environment, a government job often appears as a true lifesaver.

Furthermore, the financial incentives are hard to ignore. The recommendations of the 7th Pay Commission, for instance, have significantly enhanced the financial attractiveness of government positions. Increased salaries, along with various allowances for travel, dearness, child education, and rent, make these roles financially lucrative and provide a sense of security that many private sector jobs simply don't offer. This combination of perceived stability and tangible financial benefits makes government jobs a highly desirable option for those navigating an often unpredictable job market.

Bridging the Skill Gap and Risk Aversion

Another significant factor contributing to the continued popularity of government jobs among the youth is the prevalent skill gap. Many college graduates emerge from their academic institutions without the fundamental skills demanded by modern industries. This leaves them at a disadvantage, often forcing them to either accept lower-paying private-sector jobs or prepare for government jobs, which often prioritize general knowledge and rote learning over specialised skills.

Beyond the skill scarcity, a societal inclination towards risk-taking mechanisms also plays a role. The private sector, with its inherent uncertainties and demands for adaptability, may not appeal to those who prefer a more predictable career path. Government jobs with their established structures and perceived job security offer comfort for those who are less inclined to take on the risks associated with entrepreneurial ventures or highly competitive corporate environments.

The Challenges Faced by General Category Candidates in Securing Government Jobs

In recent years, a growing concern has been voiced among aspiring job seekers in India, especially those belonging to the general category: Why has it become increasingly difficult for general category candidates to secure government jobs? This question reflects the sentiments of a large section of the youth today, and while the concern is valid, the issue is deeply rooted in the structure of recruitment policies and reservation systems.

One of the primary reasons for the difficulty lies in the reservation system that governs public sector recruitment. A significant portion of government job vacancies is reserved for candidates from the Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST) categories. This system was originally designed to uplift historically disadvantaged communities, and while its intentions are noble, it has also created an imbalance for general category aspirants.

Even though the number of applicants from SC/ST backgrounds tends to be lower, a substantial percentage of positions is reserved for them. On the other hand, the general category, which often constitutes the largest pool of applicants, competes for a much smaller slice of the pie. This leads to intense competition among general category candidates, thereby reducing their chances despite potentially high qualifications or scores.

Attempt Limits and Age Relaxations: An Unequal Framework

Another major hurdle is the difference in the number of attempts and age limits for various categories. For instance, when it comes to prestigious exams like the UPSC (Union Public Service Commission), general category candidates are allowed a maximum of six attempts and only until the age of 32. In contrast, SC/ST candidates enjoy the benefit of unlimited attempts up to the age of 37.

This disparity in eligibility criteria further leads to the difficulties faced by general-category students, who often find themselves constrained by both time and opportunity. The extended window for reserved category candidates allows them more flexibility and chances to prepare thoroughly, while general candidates must perform under tighter restrictions.

Rising Above Challenges: A Call for Perseverance

While these systemic challenges may seem discouraging, it is important for candidates from all categories to maintain a positive and determined outlook. The competitive landscape is indeed demanding, but it is also a test of resilience and dedication. Success in government exams, or any endeavour for that matter, comes from consistent hard work, discipline and a refusal to give up.

Swami Vivekananda’s timeless words remain relevant today: “Arise, awake, and stop not till the goal is reached.” These words serve as a powerful reminder that while the path may be uneven, the journey is still achievable for those who persist.

Conclusion

The intersection of unemployment and the ongoing obsession with government jobs is a critical issue that demands immediate attention and open discussion. Every opinion is valuable in understanding and addressing this complex societal phenomenon. In no way through this article we intend to denigrate or disrespect through our viewpoints on government jobs. But, it is important for one must understand the ground realities rather than being on the “Ivory towers”.

References

. . .

Discus