+ Follow
Photo by Donald Tong: Pexels

Why does any person break the law? To what extent is it the result of their environment, genetics, or some blend of both? Psychologists have been curious about these types of questions for generations, as has every criminologist. To deal with crime and encourage transformation, we must establish what makes a person a criminal.

From the psychological and cognitive to the emotional being, an in-depth probe into criminal psychology is explained by real-world cases like the Kolkata rape case along with popular TV series reference points such as 'Vincenzo' & 'Vigilante'.

Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels

What Shapes a Criminal Mind?

What causes a person to commit crime is one of the most elusive questions that criminologists can ask, and all too often, the answer is found nestled inside a seemingly endless debate over whether it is "nature" or "nurture." Are criminals born or made? Criminality is not wholly defined by one factor but is a combination of biological predisposition and environmental factors. A prevalent view is that criminals are victims of circumstances beyond their control. However, this viewpoint is increasingly being challenged. As noted, psychologist Stanton E. Samenow argues, it is essential to focus on how individuals make decisions rather than solely on why they commit crimes. This shift in perspective leads to a better understanding of the criminal mind.

Stanton E. Samenow quotes that "the criminal thinks differently than the rest of us. His thought processes are unique and often devoid of empathy."

The Role of Biology and Genetics

Cesare Lombroso, an Italian criminologist of the late 19th century, believed that criminals were biologically distinct from non-criminals and often attributed certain physical features to criminality. While his ideas have fallen out of favor, contemporary research now allows that genetics may do some predisposing for impulsivity, aggression, or antisocial behavior. Moreover, some criminals actually have a "broken brain"—shriveled areas of their frontal lobes that impair decision-making and increase impulsive behavior.

Biological factors certainly have some role to play in modifying our behavior, but the mind is capable of changing the brain; there is also a reversible ability where you can change a developmentally impaired brain concerning natural environmental situations, says Dr. Adrian Raine, who is a neuro-criminologist from USC. The story underscores the idea that criminality is a complex interplay of nature and nurture.

Environmental Influences: Poverty, Trauma, and Social Circumstances

While we should not underestimate the role of poverty and a difficult upbringing in crime, the situation is less black and white. The failure to enable some disadvantaged backgrounds the option of not resorting to criminality is matched by the reality that many criminals have been raised in solid families. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), offenders are more likely to have been exposed as children to violence, abuse, family stress or discord. But those are correlative, because many people with such risk factors never go on to commit crimes. The real mark will be how those people live with difficulty.

Most criminals feel that they are the product of their environment while never coming to terms with actually committing the crime. For example, the recent Kolkata rape case shows to what extent public attitudes can legitimize crime. The abusers often justify their misbehavior with twisted interpretations of power and authority over other people. The case underscores how it was vital to go beyond punishing individual behaviors and focus on the responses of entire communities that make such attitudes fester.

Psychopathy and Antisocial Personality Disorder

Criminal behavior is closely connected to antisocial personality disorder (ASPD) and psychopathy. ASPD sees past on possessing no guilt in violating the rights of others and oftentimes commit violent or fraudulent acts for their own benefit. Psychopaths are mainly characterized by a lack of empathy or conscience, poor impulse control, and manipulativeness; they do not see their actions as immoral but as ways to achieve control and power. In this vein, Dr. Stanton Samenow wrote that 'crime is not an activity of desperation for many offenders but rather something they deliberate over as a source of excitement or a means to control—to wield power over others.’

Childhood Trauma and Crime

Psychological development can be inherently compromised long-term following exposure to various forms of childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, and violence. Trauma may interfere with the development of emotional regulation and decision-making strategies, increasing the risk for future criminal behavior, as suggested by some researchers. But again, not every child who experienced trauma is a criminal. How people adapt to these early experiences is immensely important in predicting the course of their lives.

Drugs, Mental Illness, and the Criminal Personality

The role that substance abuse, mental illness, and crime play in human behavior has been well studied. Studies generally find that the mentally ill or drug addicts who are not treated for their condition break the law more often than people without these conditions. However, a more careful examination would show that the proclivity for criminal behavior is the most critical determiner. Individuals with criminal predilections may be driven to drugs or mental health disease as a consequence of the inherently dangerous lifestyle. But again, drugs and mental health issues can exacerbate maladaptive behavior and poor judgment, so the connection between antisocial tendencies and criminality can be a much messier relationship than it initially appears to be.

"The criminal mind is a complex tapestry, woven with threads of drugs, mental illness, and a deeply ingrained criminal personality. Unraveling this intricate web is essential to understanding the true nature of criminality."

Media Influence: The Romanticization of Crime

With the enormous amount of technology being used today, the media influences people more. Crime stories spread like wildfire and have a domino effect on society. In general, crime dramas and movies are blamed for romanticizing criminal acts that make it look like they are exciting to do or even the right thing to do. For example, recent shows such as the Korean dramas ‘Vincenzo’ and ‘Vigilante’ have been branded for their portrayal and sentimentalization of a character who is morally ambiguous but makes use of similar gendered violent and coercive behaviors in the name of providing justice.

It is easy to pass these off as just for fun, but the ramifications of that are in actuality affecting real life. When we are fed something day in and day out, no matter what it is, honestly, the bigger threat is people becoming immune to crime, thus turning the lines between right and wrong into a mushy mess for many who do not know any better.

Breaking the Cycle: Rehabilitation or Habilitation?

This is one of the reasons there are such high levels of recidivism, and so many ex-convicts end up back behind bars after having served their sentences. Most traditional parole programs try to rebuild the person back to where they were before, being law-abiding—and yielding then that in order for something to be restored means that it existed initially—a flawed foundation for many bones. People such as Samenow preach, "You need habilitation," that is, teaching the very skills that some individuals have never learned.

Ethical Considerations in Understanding the Criminal Mind

The study of the criminal mind is fraught with ethical dilemmas; psychologists need to strike a balance between contemplating behavior and refraining from justifying it. O. Hobart Mowrer pointed out that such an overemphasis on psychological origins in psychoanalysis might promote sociopathy by downplaying accountability. Also, the media coverage on why criminals turn into criminals needs to be the duty of truthtellers; one pended interview can change public understanding of crime and a swing of policy from curing the disease towards its symptoms.

Conclusion

The criminal mind is a multifaceted conundrum that takes many shapes—from genetics and childhood trauma to cognitive distortions and antisocial behavior. Society needs to have a deep sense of these psychological underpinnings with respect to the crime in order to fight it unbiasedly. By focusing on habilitation instead of punishment and addressing root causes while holding media accountable for responsible portrayals of crime, meaningful steps can be taken towards creating safer communities.

As Stanton Samenow aptly puts it, "The lesson of neuro is that thoughts change brains." Understanding and changing the criminal mindset is the key to breaking the cycle of crime and fostering rehabilitation.

.    .    .

Reference:


Discus