Oh! Manipur, Wipe Your Tears!

The ethnic violence in Manipur, which began on 3 May 2023, highlights deep-rooted tensions between the Meitei community, predominantly residing in the Imphal Valley, and the Kuki-Zo tribal communities in the surrounding hill areas. The conflict, stemming from long-standing disputes over land rights, political representation, and identity, has had devastating consequences.

Key Impacts of the Violence (as of 3 May 2024):

Casualties:

• Deaths: 221 people killed (official figures).
• Injuries: Over 1,000 reported injured.
• Missing Persons: 32 individuals remain unaccounted for.
• Displacement: Approximately 60,000 people displaced from their homes. 
• Destruction of Property: Burnt Houses: 4,786 houses destroyed.
• Vandalized Religious Structures: 386, including temples and churches. 
• Unofficial Figures: Higher numbers of casualties and damages have been reported, underscoring the potential underreporting in official data.

Underlying Causes:

The conflict revolves around issues of ethnic identity, political and economic power, and land ownership:

• Meitei Demands: A key trigger was the Meitei community’s push for Scheduled Tribe status, which would grant them access to certain affirmative action benefits. Tribal communities perceived this as a threat to their rights and privileges.
• Land and Resource Conflicts: The hills are constitutionally protected for tribal habitation, and the Meitei community's demand for access to these areas exacerbated tensions.

Broader Implications:

The violence in Manipur is a stark reminder of the fragility of ethnic harmony and the challenges of governing diverse societies. The long-term resolution will require addressing historical grievances, ensuring equitable distribution of resources, and fostering inclusive governance mechanisms.

Causes of the Manipur Ethnic Violence

The immediate trigger for the violence in Manipur can be traced to a dispute over affirmative action policies. These policies, often referred to as reservations, positive discrimination, or alternative access, aim to benefit marginalized groups by providing opportunities in education, employment, and political representation.

Proximate Cause:

On 14 April 2023, the Manipur High Court, responding to a writ petition, directed the state government to recommend to the central government the inclusion of the Meitei community in the Scheduled Tribe (ST) list. This directive sparked significant tension:

Meitei Perspective: The majority Meitei community, residing predominantly in the Imphal Valley, argued that they were disadvantaged by their exclusion from the ST list, particularly regarding land rights and access to affirmative action benefits. Kuki-Zo and Tribal Communities’ Perspective: The hill-dwelling tribes opposed this demand, fearing it would dilute their existing rights and protections, especially concerning land ownership in constitutionally protected tribal areas.

Legal Controversy:

The High Court's order was met with criticism: The Supreme Court of India later rebuked the decision, indicating that such sensitive issues required careful deliberation and broad consultations rather than hasty judicial directives.

Underlying and Structural Causes:

While the court ruling acted as the spark, the violence also stems from deeper, longstanding issues:

Ethnic and Cultural Tensions: 

The Meitei community (53% of Manipur’s population) dominates the Imphal Valley, while the Kuki-Zo and Naga tribes inhabit the surrounding hills. Historical grievances and competition for resources have fueled animosities. Land Ownership Disputes:

Tribal areas are constitutionally protected, with non-tribals (including the Meitei) prohibited from acquiring land there. Granting ST status to the Meitei could challenge these protections.

Identity and Representation:

The Meitei community’s push for ST status highlights broader questions about identity politics and representation in a multi-ethnic society. 

Weak Governance and Trust Deficit:

• Decades of perceived neglect, mistrust of state institutions, and uneven development have exacerbated tensions.
• The combination of these factors created a volatile situation, culminating in widespread violence when the High Court’s order reignited a longstanding grievance.

Consequences of the Manipur Ethnic Violence

The ethnic clashes in Manipur have had wide-ranging and devastating effects, highlighting both immediate impacts and underlying issues.

1. Spread of Violence

The violence was triggered during peaceful protest marches organized by the All Tribal Students’ Union Manipur (ATSUM) on 3 May 2023, opposing the Meitei demand for Scheduled Tribe (ST) status.

Initial clashes erupted near the Churachandpur and Bishnupur district border, escalating into widespread arson and violence targeting minority communities in both the Kuki-dominated Churachandpur and the Meitei-dominated Imphal Valley.

According to Reuters, within the first week, 7 Kuki and 10 Meitei individuals were killed.

2. Escalating Ethnic Divisions Meitei Insecurity:

The Meitei community has expressed concerns about the influx of refugees from Myanmar’s Sagaing region, particularly after the military coup in 2021. The region shares a border with Manipur and has contributed to increased migration, intensifying fears about demographic changes and resource competition. Kuki Grievances:

The Kuki tribes have long accused the state government of targeting their indigenous land rights and marginalizing them politically and economically.

3. Allegations Against Security Forces

The Assam Rifles, a central paramilitary force stationed in Manipur, faced allegations of siding with Kuki communities.

The Manipur government and several Meitei organizations accused Assam Rifles of enabling illegal immigration from Myanmar and obstructing law enforcement actions.

In one controversial instance, Manipur Police filed an FIR against Assam Rifles personnel for allegedly allowing Kuki militants to escape during police operations.

4. Social and Humanitarian Impact

Loss of Lives: At least 221 deaths (official figures as of May 2024) were reported, with many unofficial sources suggesting higher tolls.

Displacement:

• 60,000 people have been displaced, seeking refuge in relief camps or with relatives. Destruction of Property and Religious Structures:
• Nearly 4,786 houses were burned, and 386 religious structures (both temples and churches) were vandalized.

5. Deepened Political and Ethnic Polarization

Tensions between the state and central governments have grown, with accusations of bias and insufficient handling of the crisis.

The ethnic rift between the Meitei and Kuki-Zo tribes has deepened, threatening long term coexistence and trust among communities in Manipur.

6. Cross-Border Dimensions

The proximity of Myanmar’s Sagaing region to Manipur has complicated the conflict: Refugees fleeing Myanmar’s political turmoil have exacerbated resource pressures and ethnic tensions.

Geopolitical concerns over border security have added another layer to the issue.

Conclusion

The violence in Manipur reflects the deep-seated issues of ethnic identity, resource allocation, and governance in a fragile socio-political landscape. The immediate impacts of death, displacement, and destruction are compounded by the long-term challenge of rebuilding trust and ensuring equitable development. Without meaningful dialogue and policy interventions, the region risks prolonged instability and unrest.

What Says, Famous Sanskrit Poem from the Greatest Hindu Epic Mahabharata. Here I think it is appropriate to quote these lines

“Paritranaya Sadhoonam”
‘Vinashaya cha Dushkritam”
“Dharma Samsthapartahaya”
“Sambhavami yuge, yuge”

“Paritranaya Sadhoonam” - To protect the all good fellow people

“Vinashaya cha Dushkritam” - To destroy all evil and devils

“Dharma Samsthapartahaya” - To conquer the evil and Leading to a High Valued Principles and Moral lessons everywhere or the glory or Victory of Virtues everywhere.

“Sambhavami yuge, yuge”  - We (Good people) will born again and again.

Oh! Manipur, Please Stop the Rebellion...

We mustn’t allow India to become a land of rebellion. India is a democratic country.

We must not allow autocracy in India. We must respect the values like Non-Violence, Love, Kindness, Truth and Trustworthiness. Be kind to all. Don’t be rude. Let’s follow a peaceful path.” Unity in Diversity” is our motto.

.    .    .