Source: Jan Canty on Unsplash.com

In the popular memory of India’s independence movement, a familiar list of names recurs: Gandhi, Nehru, Patel, Bose, Bhagat Singh. Muslim participants are remembered less consistently, and often only at the margins of a story that is thought to end with Partition. Yet Muslims took part in every phase of the struggle against British rule, from the revolt of 1857 to the Quit India movement of 1942 and the negotiations of 1946. They edited newspapers that the colonial state banned, presided over the Indian National Congress, organised peasant and frontier resistance, planned armed action, and went to the gallows.

This article looks closely at three of the most prominent of them, Ashfaqulla Khan, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, and Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan, and then turns to other documented participants whose careers show how varied Muslim engagement with Indian nationalism was. The word “forgotten” needs care. None of these men is wholly unknown, and several have been honoured with stamps, institutions, and national awards. They are forgotten in a narrower sense: their stories are seldom woven into the general narrative, and the wide range of Muslim political choices is often flattened into a single story of separatism.

Why the Story Has Been Forgotten

Several forces explain the neglect. The most obvious is Partition. After 1947, the creation of Pakistan came to dominate how the last decade of colonial rule was told, and Muslim politics was often reduced to the career of the Muslim League. Historians have long argued that this is a distortion. The League won a decisive share of Muslim votes only in the elections of 1945–46, and for most of the preceding decades Muslims were divided among many parties, movements, and positions, including the Congress, the Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind, the Khudai Khidmatgars, regional parties, and the League itself (Hasan 1991; Jalal 1985).

A second reason lies in the way national history is written. A nation that wishes to present its founding struggle as a unified movement tends to remember its heroes through a few emblematic figures, and the others recede. A third is that some of the most striking Muslim contributions occurred in settings that were politically awkward after independence. Ghaffar Khan’s work was carried out in territory that became part of Pakistan, while Azad’s uncompromising opposition to Partition could be read, by different audiences, as either vindicated or defeated. The result is a record that is rich but scattered, and that is best recovered through biographies and local studies rather than general textbooks (Chandra et al. 1989; Sarkar 1983).

From 1857 to the Congress

Muslim resistance to the East India Company did not begin with the twentieth-century nationalist movement. In 1857 the last Mughal emperor, Bahadur Shah Zafar, was proclaimed the symbolic leader of the revolt in Delhi, and figures such as Maulvi Ahmadullah Shah of Faizabad and Begum Hazrat Mahal of Awadh led fighting in the north (Dalrymple 2006). The aftermath was harsh for Muslim elites in many regions, and historians have shown how the destruction of the Delhi court and the loss of official patronage pushed Muslims toward new strategies, from religious reform at Deoband to modern education at Aligarh (Metcalf 1982; Metcalf 1964).

These strategies did not point in a single political direction. Some Muslim leaders, particularly in the late nineteenth century, urged caution toward the Congress, while others joined it early. Badruddin Tyabji presided over the Congress at Madras in 1887, only two years after its founding, and Rahimtulla Sayani did so in 1896 (Hasan 1991). By the early twentieth century, a younger and more radical generation, shaped by the Balkan wars, the First World War, and pan-Islamic feeling, had begun to turn that sentiment against British rule. Among them were the two men who would become the best-known voices of the Khilafat movement and the journalists and ulama whose careers are described below.

Ashfaqulla Khan: The Revolutionary

Ashfaqulla Khan was born on 22 October 1900 in Shahjahanpur in the United Provinces, into a Pathan family. As a schoolboy, he was influenced by the arrests connected with the Mainpuri conspiracy case of 1918, and he sought out Ram Prasad Bismil, a fellow townsman and revolutionary, whom he met around 1920. The friendship that followed became one of the best-known partnerships in the history of the revolutionary movement. The two men came from different religious backgrounds, and accounts of their lives repeatedly stress the closeness that survived those differences, which makes their story an important counterweight to later narratives of mutual suspicion (Gupta 1972; Maclean 2015).

Both men were members of the Hindustan Republican Association, which aimed to overthrow colonial rule through organised armed action rather than the non-violent methods of the Congress. Revolutionary groups of this kind needed money, and in August 1925 members of the association stopped a train near Kakori, close to Lucknow, and seized government cash being carried on it. The action was planned as a fundraising raid, but it turned into a major confrontation with the state because a passenger was killed during the episode. The authorities responded with a large-scale hunt and a lengthy trial.

Most of the participants were arrested within weeks, but Ashfaqulla evaded capture for more than a year. He is said to have worked in Bihar and later in Banaras before trying to make his way abroad, and he was arrested in Delhi in 1926 after a betrayal by an acquaintance. At the Kakori trial, he was convicted and sentenced to death. Accounts record that he refused offers of leniency in return for testimony against his comrades. He was executed at Faizabad jail on 19 December 1927 at the age of twenty-seven, the same day as Bismil and Roshan Singh, and shortly after Rajendra Lahiri had been hanged elsewhere. He also wrote Urdu verse under the pen name Hasrat, and his poems are still recited in the region.

Ashfaqulla’s importance for the history of Muslim participation lies less in the scale of his actions than in what they show. The revolutionary underground, often remembered as overwhelmingly Hindu, included Muslims who were committed to a shared republic, and the colonial state treated them with the same severity. His case also reminds us that the independence movement was not confined to the Congress. A significant stream of political violence existed alongside mass non-violent politics, and its participants were drawn from several communities (Maclean 2015).

Maulana Abul Kalam Azad: Scholar, Editor, and Congress President. Abul Kalam Azad was born in Mecca in 1888 into a family of religious scholars and was brought to India as a child. He received a traditional Islamic education and, while still a young man, turned to journalism. In June 1912, he began publishing the Urdu weekly Al-Hilal from Calcutta, which combined religious argument with sharp criticism of British policy and urged Muslims to take part in the national movement. The government regarded the paper as seditious, and it was suppressed under the Press Act in 1914. Azad launched a second weekly, Al-Balagh, and when that too was banned, he was expelled from Bengal and held in Ranchi until the end of the war (Douglas 1988).

Azad entered the Congress in 1920 and supported Gandhi’s non-cooperation movement, arguing that cooperation with Hindus in the national cause was required, rather than merely permitted, by Islamic ethics. In 1923, he was elected president of the Congress at the age of thirty-five, making him the youngest person to hold that office. He was arrested during the civil disobedience campaign of 1930 and imprisoned on later occasions. In 1940, he was elected president again, and he served until 1946. Because almost the entire Congress leadership was in prison after the Quit India movement of 1942, his second term was an unusually long one, and it ended with his leading the Congress side in the discussions with the British Cabinet Mission in 1946 (Azad 1959).

Azad was also one of the most articulate Muslim opponents of the demand for Pakistan. He argued that Indian Muslims were an inseparable part of a single nation and that the idea of partition was damaging to their own interests. In 1940 he joined other nationalist Muslims in resisting the Lahore resolution, and the All India Azad Muslim Conference, which met in Delhi that year with a large attendance, was one expression of that opposition (Hasan 1991). His memoir, India Wins Freedom, offers a critical account of the final negotiations, in which he blamed both Congress and League leaders for the failure to preserve unity, although historians continue to debate his judgments (Azad 1959; Jalal 1985).

After independence, Azad became the first Minister of Education, serving from 1947 until his death in 1958. He argued for free and compulsory primary education and supported the establishment of national institutions for higher education and scientific training, among them the University Grants Commission. He was awarded the Bharat Ratna posthumously in 1992, and his birthday on 11 November is observed as National Education Day. Azad is therefore not forgotten in an absolute sense, but his career as a Muslim theologian who saw nationalism as the proper expression of his faith is often reduced to a single line in the standard accounts.

Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan: The Frontier Gandhi

Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan, known to his followers as Bacha Khan or Badshah Khan, was born in 1890 in Utmanzai in the North-West Frontier Province into a prosperous Pashtun family. He began as a social reformer, establishing schools and the reformist organisation Anjuman-i-Islah-ul-Afaghina in 1921 and launching a Pashto journal in 1928. His central concern was the education and moral renewal of the Pashtun community, a population that colonial writers routinely described as inherently violent (Gandhi 2004; Khan 1969).

In 1929 he founded the Khudai Khidmatgar, or Servants of God, whose members wore red uniforms and were therefore called the Red Shirts. What made the movement remarkable was its commitment to non-violence. Ghaffar Khan presented that commitment as an Islamic discipline of patience and service, and he trained thousands of Pashtun volunteers in it, in a region where carrying arms was a matter of honour. In 1931 the movement aligned itself with the Indian National Congress, and Ghaffar Khan became one of Gandhi’s closest associates (Easwaran 1984; Banerjee 2000).

The movement faced severe repression. On 23 April 1930, after Ghaffar Khan had been arrested during the Salt Satyagraha, a crowd gathered in the Qissa Khwani Bazaar in Peshawar, and troops and armoured vehicles were used against the unarmed demonstrators. Estimates of the number killed vary widely, and the episode is widely remembered as one of the bloodiest confrontations of the civil disobedience period. A frequently recounted detail is that a platoon of Garhwali soldiers refused to fire on the crowd and were punished for it, although the full story is still debated by historians (Banerjee 2000).

Ghaffar Khan’s opposition to Partition was as firm as Azad’s. He and the Khudai Khidmatgars argued that the Pashtuns had been left without a real choice in the referendum of 1947, which offered only a decision between India and Pakistan, and they boycotted it while calling for an autonomous Pashtun homeland. After Partition, he lived in Pakistan, where he was imprisoned or placed under restriction for many years and where the Khudai Khidmatgar movement was suppressed. He died in 1988, and in 1987 India awarded him the Bharat Ratna, the first non-citizen to receive it (Gandhi 2004). His life poses a challenge to two stereotypes at once, that of the Pashtun as inherently violent and that of the Muslim as inherently separatist.

Other Documented Participants

Beyond these three, a large number of Muslim participants are documented in the scholarly record. Maulana Hasrat Mohani, a poet and journalist, joined the Congress early in the century and was repeatedly imprisoned for his writings. He is widely credited with having moved a resolution for complete independence at the Ahmedabad session of the Congress in 1921, a demand the leadership did not then accept, and with having popularised the slogan Inquilab Zindabad, which was taken up by later revolutionaries (Hasan 1991). His political path was unusual, since he was active in the Congress, the Muslim League, and the early communist movement, and he later sat in the Constituent Assembly.

During the First World War, an extraordinary effort was made by the ulama of Deoband. Mahmud al-Hasan, the principal of the seminary, and his pupil Ubaidullah Sindhi planned a conspiracy, later called the Silk Letter Movement, which sought assistance from Afghanistan and the Ottoman empire for an uprising against British rule. The plan was exposed in 1916 when letters written on silk were intercepted, and Mahmud al-Hasan was interned in Malta (Sedition Committee 1918; Metcalf 1982). In the same period, Maulana Barkatullah and Raja Mahendra Pratap helped establish a Provisional Government of India in Kabul in December 1915, with Barkatullah as prime minister and Ubaidullah Sindhi among its ministers. These were small and short-lived ventures, but they show that Muslim scholars were prepared to take armed and international risks for Indian freedom.

The Khilafat movement of 1919–24 brought a far larger section of the Muslim population into mass politics. Muhammad Ali Jauhar and Shaukat Ali, the Ali brothers, were its best-known leaders, and for a short period the alliance between Khilafat and Gandhi’s non-cooperation campaign produced an unprecedented level of Hindu–Muslim cooperation (Minault 1982; Qureshi 1999). Hakim Ajmal Khan, a physician who served as acting president of the Congress session at Ahmedabad in 1921 and was a founder of Jamia Millia Islamia, and D M. A. Ansari, who presided over the Congress session of 1927, were among the nationalist Muslims who linked the movement to wider Muslim institutions. Zakir Husain, the future President of India, was among the early leaders of Jamia, which was established in 1920 as a national Muslim university in the spirit of non-cooperation (Hasan 1991).

Muslim clergy who stayed with the Congress deserve special mention. Maulana Husain Ahmad Madani, a leading Deobandi scholar who had been interned in Malta with Mahmud al-Hasan, argued in the late 1930s for what he called composite nationalism, the view that Muslims and non-Muslims of India could form a single nation while each community retained its religion (Madani 2005). The Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind, founded in 1919, adopted a similar position, and many of its members took part in civil disobedience and went to prison.

Muslims also served in the armed forces that the Indian National Army sought to turn against the empire. The Red Fort trials of 1945–46, in which Hindu, Muslim, and Sikh officers were tried together, were a major moment in the late nationalist movement, and the Muslim officer Shah Nawaz Khan was one of the three principal defendants. Abid Hasan Safrani, an INA officer, is credited with the greeting Jai Hind, which became the army’s salutation and, later, a national slogan (Fay 1993). Women, too, played a role. Abadi Bano Begum, known as Bi Amma, the mother of the Ali brothers, spoke at Khilafat meetings and supported the movement’s fundraising, and Muslim women activists helped to mobilise the public for boycotts and picketing in the 1920s and 1930s (Minault 1998).

Debates and Cautions

A responsible account should avoid two errors. The first is the habit of treating Muslim participation as an afterthought. The second, which appears in some popular writing, is to turn the record into a counter-narrative in which Muslims alone carried the struggle or in which those who supported the League are written out of the story. The historical record shows something more complicated. Muslim opinion was divided; many Muslims came to believe that their interests required a separate state, and the League’s growth in the 1940s was not an invention of the British alone (Jalal 1985; Hasan 1997). The nationalist Muslims discussed here were an important current, but they were a minority within the community by 1946 and were often critiqued from within it.

There are also unresolved questions about evidence. Many accounts of Ashfaqulla Khan and other revolutionaries rely on later commemorative literature, memoirs, and oral tradition, and details such as dates of arrest or the exact wording of last statements differ from source to source. Casualty figures for Qissa Khwani Bazaar are contested. Historians writing about these figures therefore need to separate what is documented in colonial records and contemporary sources from what has entered public memory through repetition.

The Muslims discussed in this article were revolutionaries, editors, scholars, soldiers, doctors, and others who came from different regions and held very different views about religion and politics. Ashfaqulla Khan died young on the gallows after refusing to betray his comrades. Maulana Azad turned a theological education into a career in journalism and then in the highest ranks of the Congress. Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan trained a violent society in the discipline of non-violence and paid for his convictions with decades of imprisonment. Around them stood many others, from the Deoband conspirators to the Ali brothers, from Hasrat Mohani to the officers of the Indian National Army.

To recover their stories is not to deny the importance of Partition or the Muslim League, but to restore the full range of Muslim political choice in the last decades of colonial rule. A history of the freedom struggle that includes them is more accurate, and it shows that the idea of a shared Indian future was held, argued over, and defended at great personal cost by people of every faith.

References:

  1. Azad, M. A. K. (1959). India Wins Freedom: An Autobiographical Narrative. Orient Longman.
  2. Banerjee, M. (2000). The Pathan Unarmed: Opposition and Memory in the North West Frontier. School of American Research Press.
  3. Chandra, B., Mukherjee, M., Mukherjee, A., Mahajan, S., and Panikkar, K. N. (1989). India’s Struggle for Independence, 1857–1947. Penguin Books India.
  4. Dalrymple, W. (2006). The Last Mughal: The Fall of a Dynasty, Delhi, 1857. Bloomsbury.
  5. Douglas, I. H. (1988). Abul Kalam Azad: An Intellectual and Religious Biography (G. Minault and C. W. Troll, Eds.). Oxford University Press.
  6. Easwaran, E. (1984). A Man to Match His Mountains: Badshah Khan, Nonviolent Soldier of Islam. Nilgiri Press.
  7. Fay, P. W. (1993). The Forgotten Army: India’s Armed Struggle for Independence, 1942–1945. University of Michigan Press.
  8. Gandhi, R. (2004). Ghaffar Khan: Nonviolent Badshah of the Pakhtuns. Viking/Penguin India. Gupta, M. (1972). History of the Indian Revolutionary Movement. Somaiya Publications. Hasan, M. (1991). Nationalism and Communal Politics in India, 1885–1930. Manohar. Hasan, M. (1997). Legacy of a Divided Nation: India’s Muslims since Independence. Hurst.
  9. Jalal, A. (1985). The Sole Spokesman: Jinnah, the Muslim League and the Demand for Pakistan. Cambridge University Press.
  10. Khan, A. G. (1969). My Life and Struggle: Autobiography of Badshah Khan (as narrated to K. B. Narang). Hind Pocket Books.
  11. Madani, H. A. (2005). Composite Nationalism and Islam (Muttahida Qaumiyat aur Islam) (M. A. Hussain and H. Imam, Trans.). Manohar.
  12. Maclean, K. (2015). A Revolutionary History of Interwar India: Violence, Image, Voice and Text. Hurst.
  13. Metcalf, B. D. (1982). Islamic Revival in British India: Deoband, 1860–1900. Princeton University Press.
  14. Metcalf, T. R. (1964). The Aftermath of Revolt: India, 1857–1870. Princeton University Press.
  15. Minault, G. (1982). The Khilafat Movement: Religious Symbolism and Political Meaning in India. Columbia University Press.
  16. Minault, G. (1998). Secluded Scholars: Women’s Education and Muslim Social Reform in Colonial India. Oxford University Press.
  17. Qureshi, M. N. (1999). Pan-Islam in British Indian Politics: A Study of the Khilafat Movement, 1918–1924. Brill.
  18. Sarkar, S. (1983). Modern India, 1885–1947. Macmillan.
  19. Sedition Committee (1918). Report of the Sedition Committee, 1918. Superintendent, Government Printing, Calcutta.

.    .    .