In some parts of the world, the practice of exchanging human lives for material goods remains a chilling reality, often masked by the veil of tradition. While the concept of bride prices and dowries is familiar across many cultures, it is in certain regions that this custom is twisted into a darker, more disturbing form. Here, brides are traded like livestock, and their worth is sometimes measured in terms of livestock or, more unsettlingly, cash, with some trades even being valued less than a buffalo. This is the grim reality of the "Molki" (The Bought Ones) in India. Decades of female feticide in states like Haryana and Rajasthan created a massive shortage of women. Men cannot find local wives.
The Tradition of Bride Price: A Double-Edged Sword
The payment of bride prices is not in and of itself exploitative. In some cultures, a bride price or a dowry is a token of commitment and can be a source of financial security for the bride’s family. But in areas where gender inequalities are rampant, these institutions can be exploited to commoditize women and make them no more than a piece of property. Instead of marriage, they "purchase" women from poverty-stricken regions (Bengal, Bihar, Jharkhand) for ₹10,000–₹30,000. For context, a healthy buffalo costs ₹60,000+. In these markets, a human woman is literally cheaper than livestock.
In different regions of Africa, Asia, and Oceania, bride price payments have conventionally functioned as a means of reimbursing a bride’s family for her lost labor and a way of formalizing a contract between two families. However, in some regions, these payments have become a nightmarish form of human trafficking and exploitation, where a woman is considered a negotiator in a game of trade.
The Economics of Human Brides: Worth Less Than Livestock?
In some regions, the cost of a human bride has been astonishingly low. In the Global Human Rights Report, there was a specific example where a young woman was purchased as a bride for $50 - an amount less than the price of a buffalo in many African cultures. Such purchases typically take place within a cultural context where social and economic pressures drive people to enter into these transactions. Women are typically prevented from establishing any legal agency or autonomy through poverty, lack of education, and entrenched patriarchal systems.
In some instances, local law recognizes or ignores this practice because cultural and religious beliefs provide support for the practices, making it extremely difficult to change. Additionally, the value of the bride is often determined based upon her perceived value as a labourer (often women have little or no access to labour rights), a child bearer, or a 'valuable' wife within a patriarchal society. This perspective that "you can buy a woman for less than a buffalo" highlights the systemic dehumanization that is pervasive in this form of abuse.
The Consequences of the Silent Trade:
Although this custom may be seen as out-of-date by some, the impact of this kind of work on the women involved is still felt in society today. Women working in these fields experience physical and emotional abuse, lack of control, and a lifetime of being treated as property. Some are forced into marriage with men they do not know or have any interest in while others are trafficked into sexual slavery or domestic servitude. These women are not treated as wives; they are Breeding Stock and Farm Labor. They have no legal rights, no family support, and if the husband dies, they are often resold to a male relative or kicked out of the village.
When a woman is sold for such a low price, it is also typical that her new "owner" will not be able to provide her with proper care for her well-being or provide her with a means of self-sufficiency in an affordable manner, which will result in continued poverty, mistreatment, and neglect. The emotional consequences for a woman in this situation are trauma and despair as well as being turned into a product and not a human.
Additionally, this practice continues from generation to generation creating a cycle of poverty, gender discrimination and violence which is difficult to end. Many young girls are forced into early marriages when they are too young to make their own decisions about their daily lives or their futures. As a result, they will never receive an education or find a suitable job to support themselves.
How to Combat the Silent Trade
Ending this disturbing practice requires a multifaceted approach that combines legal reform, education, and cultural change. Advocacy organizations and human rights groups have long been pushing for stricter laws and more enforcement of existing laws against human trafficking and child marriage. Education is also key in empowering women and girls to understand their rights and pursue alternative paths to financial independence.
Programs on a community level that try to work in accordance with local culture to influence attitudes concerning the worth of women are quite important in this respect. Through engaging men, leaders, and elders, it is possible to initiate an interaction where patriarchal culture can be challenged and a new definition concerning the worth of women can be gained, which won't be based on either money or other transactional elements.
In addition, international influence and collaborations with governments can bring about better policies, law enforcement, and economic opportunities for women, making a silent trade such as human brides unnecessary.
Case Study:
In a remote village in West Africa, a young woman named Adama, barely 16 years old, was offered in marriage to a wealthier farmer in exchange for cattle, land, and other valuables. The groom’s family negotiated a bride price equivalent to 3 buffaloes, a few dozen goats, and an impressive sum of local currency.
However, what made Adama’s case notable was the fact that, due to the severity of the drought in the region, the groom’s family couldn’t afford to complete the trade. With this, in a last attempt to seal the bargain, they reduced the price to a single buffalo. As a symbol of their commitment to the bargain, a trade of a buffalo took place in the market square in front of the villagers, with Adama silent by her father’s side, oblivious of her fate.
She symbolized an existing "silent trade" in parts of Africa and the whole world where girls and women are viewed as commodities, with their consent not playing any role in a trade or economic negotiation. The community treated the arrangement as a natural progression, seeing Adama as a part of the transaction. Though the outside world views it as shocking to transact a human bride in exchange for a buffalo, for the people involved, it was completely normal.
Key Themes to Explore:
Bride Price and the Economic Exchange: In certain cultures, a bride price is paid to compensate the family ‘losing’ their daughter to marry into another family. As a result, in these cultures, marriage becomes an economic transaction rather than a personal relationship.
Modern Ideals/traditional Practices: In many societies, many people believe that traditions such as bride price are outdated or oppressive because of the current global push for women's rights; however, the way a particular culture views a bride price is still entrenched in that culture.
Silence of the Trade: Adama’s silence represents the inability of many women in some societies to voice their own opinions or control their own destiny due to patriarchal customs. The very fact that Adama cannot speak for herself demonstrates how such traditions have stripped women of their humanity and reduced them to being commodities on a wider scale within a particular culture.
Buffalo Symbolism: Quality and quantity of wealth and status in these communities are represented by the presence of buffalos. As a result, the worth of women within their own culture can often be determined by the material goods that exist in their culture rather than by the human beings (women) themselves.
Shifting the Value of Women
The phrase "cheaper than a buffalo" is a harsh reminder of just how deeply patriarchy is ingrained in society, where the value of human life, particularly of women, can be measured less than the cost of an animal, or of land and goods. In this day and age when the need for gender equality is widely recognized in the world, this culture of negative practices is in dire need of the spotlight in order to bring about a positive change in their lives.
Although the silent trade in human brides may not make news in the same way other emerging issues do, it is just as damaging. Stopping this practice means more than simply destroying an old tradition because it’s important to make sure all females, regardless of where they were raised, are valued for being human, not for being a commodity.
References: