Image by falco from Pixabay
Thirty-six districts were certified free of manual scavenging, yet Maharashtra recorded India’s highest sewer deaths. Now the count itself decides justice.
Two Numbers One Reply
Let me begin with two numbers from the same answer in Parliament. Zero. 332.
Replies tabled in the Lok Sabha in July and early August 2026 put the number of sanitation workers who died while cleaning sewers and septic tanks at 332. The count runs from 1 January 2021 to 30 June 2026 and covers 18 states and union territories [6][7]. The same answers state that no death was reported due to manual scavenging [6][10].
Both statements can be true at once, and this article explains how. First, the matter of place. Maharashtra recorded 58 of those 332 deaths, the highest of any state [8]. Yet the Maharashtra government told the Bombay High Court that all 36 of its districts had been declared free of manual scavenging, with certificates sent to the Centre on 2 August 2023 [1].
A district that is certified free and a state that tops the death table are not necessarily contradicting each other. They are measuring different things. Everything I want to say lives in the gap between a certificate and a count.
I will be careful throughout. These are official statements and court records. I describe what they say, I mark the places where I offer my own analysis, and I do not name any of the workers who died.
Words That Decide Who Counts
The law that governs this subject is the Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013 [5]. A handful of terms decide who is counted and who is not, so it helps to hold them in mind.
Please keep the first two terms apart. The rest of the argument depends on that distinction.
The Day the Court Said Enough
The case is Shramik Janata Sangh v. State of Maharashtra, Writ Petition No. 1570 of 2023. The petitioners were a registered trade union, the father of a sanitation worker who died in a septic tank in Mumbra in 2022, and a writer who volunteers with a youth organisation. They asked the court to strike down Item 11 and to compel the State to identify and compensate every worker who had died [1].
The State’s reply was that 36 districts had been declared free of manual scavenging and that 81 deaths had been compensated at ₹10 lakh each, a total of ₹8.10 crore. In its view, nothing survived in the petition [1].
On 13 August 2026 a bench of Justices Bharati Dangre and Manjusha Deshpande rejected that view. The judgment, written by Justice Deshpande, opens by observing that a country proud of reaching the Moon still lets a caste system push some citizens into work below human dignity [1]. It then did five things:
The bench also noted that two families had managed to reach a court, and that many others in the same position could not [1]. One of those cases came from the Aurangabad Bench. On 6 July 2026, in Sharda Maroti Chopwad v. State of Maharashtra, it held the State liable for ₹30 lakh each for two men who died in a private septic tank in Nanded, about five years earlier [2][14].
Four Cracks in the Official Record
A close reading of the judgment and the parliamentary answers shows four places where the official record does not line up with itself. None of them requires any accusation of bad faith. They are structural.
Crack one: definition. The Ministry reports zero manual scavenging deaths and 332 hazardous-cleaning deaths for 2021 to June 2026. A separate reply put the figure at 498 for January 2019 to June 2026, again with no manual scavenging deaths [9]. Under the Act these are different categories, so the statements do not formally conflict [10]. But a reader who sees only the first line learns nothing about the workers who died.
Crack two: time. The 36 certificates reached the Centre in August 2023. The State’s affidavit came in July 2024. When the High Court asked on 20 August 2024 whether the State still stood by its claim, its counsel said the declarations reflected the position when they were issued, not the position then. The petitioners meanwhile listed instances of continued manual scavenging in April and August 2024 [1]. A certificate is a photograph of one moment.
Crack three: unit. The State’s figure of 81 deaths covers persons identified as manual scavengers. The court observed that the affidavit gave no information at all on those who died in hazardous cleaning, which is why it ordered a fresh identification exercise [1]. Set that beside two other Maharashtra numbers. The national table lists 58 deaths for 2021 to June 2026 [8]. A Union-commissioned social audit of five locations (Mumbai, Pune, Parbhani, Satara and Shirur) documented 18 deaths between 2021 and 2024 [13]. Three counts, three units, three periods, and no way to reconcile them.
Crack four: audit. Asked in Parliament whether the “nil” certificates had ever been audited, the Ministry answered “No, Sir” [10]. The same answers leave other questions open. Compensation for 48 of the 332 deaths is listed as not confirmed. FIRs were lodged for 110 of 166 deaths over a three-year window [10]. Maharashtra’s rehabilitation record is thin too: the court found that apart from Jalgaon, Nanded and Raigad, no district had taken any step towards rehabilitation [1].
| Crack | What the record says | What it leaves out |
| Definition | Zero manual scavenging deaths; 332 hazardous-cleaning deaths | That both involve the same human risk |
| Time | 36 districts certified free in August 2023 | The State conceded in 2024 that the claim reflected an earlier moment |
| Unit | 81 deaths among identified manual scavengers | Deaths in hazardous cleaning, until the court ordered a count |
| Audit | Every district has declared itself free | Any independent check of the certificates |
Crack What the record says What it leaves out
Definition Zero manual scavenging deaths; 332 hazardous-cleaning deaths That both involve the same human risk
Time 36 districts certified free in August 2023 The State conceded in 2024 that the claim reflected an earlier moment
Unit 81 deaths among identified manual scavengers Deaths in hazardous cleaning, until the court ordered a count
Audit Every district has declared itself free Any independent check of the certificates
Falling or Rising No One Can Prove
I began this article assuming that the toll was rising. The official data does not support that. As tabulated from the Ministry’s answers, deaths were 62 in 2021, 88 in 2022, 65 in 2023, 54 in 2024, 47 in 2025 and 16 in the first half of 2026 [10]. On paper that is a decline.
Civil society counts disagree sharply. The Safai Karmachari Andolan has documented 593 deaths between January 2021 and July 2026 [11], against the official 332 up to June. It has also recorded 101 deaths in the first 188 days of 2026 [12], against the official 16 for the first half. These are not like-for-like comparisons. The end dates differ, and activist counts may include sewage treatment plants, drains and manholes that official tables do not.
Even so, a gap of this size cannot be explained by a few weeks. It could reflect reporting lag, narrower recording rules or under-reporting. The Ministry’s own answers hint at lag, since compensation is unconfirmed for 20 of the 47 deaths in 2025 and 10 of the 16 in 2026 [10]. Here is my honest conclusion: I cannot tell which explanation is right, and neither can anyone outside the system. That is the real finding. The argument is not about whether the toll is rising or falling. It is that nobody independent can currently check.
The Count Now Carries a Price
Before 13 August 2026, counting a death in Maharashtra mattered mainly for the record. Now it carries a price. Within six months, which is around mid-February 2027, the State must identify every hazardous-cleaning death and pay ₹30 lakh per family [1]. The State may recover the money from employers, but the immediate obligation sits with the State.
Here I offer my own analysis, not a finding of any court. When the body that counts the deaths is also the body that must pay for each one, it has a structural interest in a smaller number. I am not suggesting anyone will act on that interest. A well-designed system does not rely on goodwill to resist it.
As of 17 November 2026, I could not find any public report of an appeal against the judgment or of how far the State has complied. The eight-week window for named families closed in early October. Delay has a human cost. In the Aurangabad case, the owners had promised small sums to the families, yet only part was paid, and the court order came five years after the deaths [2][14].
Reform That Finally Breaks New Ground
Liability is settled in Maharashtra, so it is not the reform to propose. The open question is who verifies the numbers on which liability now depends. Five measures follow from the record above.
What You Can Do Today
You do not need to be an official to act. Here is a short checklist for any reader.
A Certificate Is Not Proof
Go back to the two numbers: zero and 332. Both can be true under the law, and that is exactly the difficulty. A declaration of freedom measures a legal category. It does not measure whether a worker walks out of a tank alive.
The Bombay High Court has now said the State must count, pay and rehabilitate, and must not hide behind the identity of the employer. Whether that promise becomes real depends on something unglamorous: a count that someone other than the payer can check. Until then, a certificate tells us what an office declared. It does not tell us what happened below the ground.
References