The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) completed one hundred years in 2025, and its centenary has produced both celebration and a fresh round of argument. Few Indian organisations are described in such opposite terms: to its admirers it is a disciplined volunteer movement devoted to service and cultural pride, while to its critics it is the organisational core of a majoritarian political project. This article sets out the basic facts and then separates the main controversies, because treating them as one bundle tends to produce heat rather than clarity. Wherever a claim is contested, it is attributed to the people making it. Numbers in square brackets refer to the sources listed at the end.
The RSS has been banned three times in independent India. The first ban came on 4 February 1948, days after Mahatma Gandhi was shot by Nathuram Godse, and it was lifted in 1949 after the organisation committed to a written constitution and to loyalty to the Constitution and the national flag. The second came during the Emergency in 1975, when the Indira Gandhi government banned the RSS along with other organisations; it was lifted in 1977 after the Janata Party came to power. The third followed the demolition of the Babri Masjid on 6 December 1992: the ban was imposed on 10 December and lifted on 4 June 1993 after a tribunal headed by Justice Bahri held it unjustified.
What these episodes mean is disputed. RSS-aligned writers present the bans as political acts that failed and left the organisation stronger. Critics respond that a ban is not the same as vindication, and that the 1948 ban order itself recorded the reasons for it.
The RSS role in the independence movement is one of the most argued historical questions about it. Supporters note that Hedgewar had been a Congress worker and was jailed for his part in the movements of the early 1920s and for the Salt Satyagraha of 1930. They add that swayamsevaks took part as individuals and that some RSS-linked people sheltered revolutionaries. This view was restated in December 2025 in response to remarks by Karnataka minister Priyank Kharge questioning the RSS record.
Critics, including the authors writing in The Wire and Counterview, argue that Hedgewar's participation was personal rather than organisational, that the Sangh did not join the Congress-led campaigns, and that Golwalkar later wrote that during 1942 the routine work of the Sangh simply continued. They also argue that claims of RSS participation in the freedom movement became prominent only decades after independence. Historians therefore agree on some facts, such as Hedgewar's imprisonment, and differ on how to interpret them: as evidence of a nationalist tradition, or as the exception that proves the organisation's detachment.
The Sangh's connection to Gandhi's killing is the most sensitive of the debates, and it helps to separate three questions. The first is whether the organisation was legally found responsible, and the answer is no: the Kapur Commission, appointed in 1966, is cited by RSS-aligned writers for its finding that the RSS as such could not be held responsible for the murder. The second is what the evidence says about wider networks. The historian Mridula Mukherjee, for example, cites the same commission's conclusion that the facts were destructive of any theory other than a conspiracy by Savarkar and his group, and points to the overlap between RSS and Hindu Mahasabha members. The third is Godse's own relationship to the RSS, which different sources describe in different terms, and which the organisation and its critics characterise differently. Because these are distinct questions, a statement that the RSS was cleared and a statement that the commission found troubling links are not necessarily in contradiction; they answer different questions.
Supporters credit the RSS with discipline, service work and a renewed pride in Indian culture. Bhagwat has said that, in his understanding, Hindu is not a narrowly religious label and that anyone native to India is a Hindu, while also stating that membership of the RSS is open only to Hindus. Critics argue that Hindutva, as a political ideology, is majoritarian and that it sits uneasily with India's plural constitutional order. They also raise concerns about caste hierarchy, the place of women in the organisation and the treatment of minorities. The two sides frequently use the same words to mean different things, which is why it is worth asking, in any given argument, whether the speaker is describing the RSS's stated ideals, its day-to-day activity, or the political outcomes its critics associate with it.
In November 2025, Bhagwat told an audience in Bengaluru that the RSS is a body of individuals recognised under the law, that it is not unconstitutional, and that it therefore has no need to register; he added that even Hindu Dharma is not registered. This came as Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge renewed a call to ban the RSS, and as his son Priyank Kharge, a Karnataka minister, questioned the Sangh's registration and sources of funding.
The dispute returned in June 2026, when Priyank Kharge wrote to Bhagwat asking the RSS to clarify its legal status, funding, income, expenditure and assets. Kharge pointed to the scale of the organisation, including more than 4,100 daily shakhas in Karnataka alone, as the reason scrutiny was warranted. Bhagwat dismissed the demand as politics, said the RSS holds its activities openly and takes no government funds, and said registration is needed only by those seeking such funds. RSS and BJP leader Ram Madhav likewise argued that registration is mandatory only for associations that seek government funding or engage in commercial activity, and called the demand frivolous. Kharge rejected the comparison with Hindu Dharma, calling it flawed, and said organisations with public influence must be open to scrutiny; Karnataka Congress leaders added that Hinduism belongs to all Hindus and not to one organisation. Commentators sympathetic to Kharge have framed the question as one about democratic accountability.
Two separate questions are bundled here, and it helps to keep them apart. One is legal: whether any law requires an organisation of this kind to register. Bhagwat and Madhav say it does not; Kharge says the organisation should still follow the law and disclose its affairs. The other is political: whether an organisation with this reach should, as a matter of public accountability, volunteer disclosures that the law may not demand. The first question has an answer that can be checked against statute; the second is a matter of judgement.
Debates | Argued by supporters | Argued by critics |
Freedom struggle | Hedgewar was jailed in Congress-led movements; swayamsevaks took part individually. | The RSS as an organisation stayed aloof; Hedgewar's jail terms were personal; Golwalkar urged routine work in 1942. |
Gandhi assassination | The Kapur Commission found the RSS, as such, was not responsible. | The same commission pointed to a Savarkar-led conspiracy and RSS/Hindu Mahasabha overlap. |
Hindutva | A cultural, inclusive idea of Bharat; service-oriented. | Majoritarian in effect; raises caste, gender and minority concerns. |
Registration | No law requires it; it takes no government funds; it is a body of individuals. | An organisation of this scale should disclose legal status, funding and tax position. |
A Note for Writers
The safest way to write about the RSS is to treat each debate as its own question, to name the person or institution making each claim, and to avoid letting an argument about one issue stand in for another. A fair account of the freedom-struggle debate says nothing about the registration row, and a finding on the Gandhi assassination does not settle what Hindutva means today. Writers should also be careful about sources: RSS-aligned publications and its critics' publications both marshal evidence selectively, so the best practice is to read both and to rely on primary documents, commission reports and court or tribunal records where they exist.
References: