Some stories go viral because of their unusual nature. Some stories spread like wildfire because they tap into a fear we think we are losing; such stories are a type of viral content. Some stories go viral as they remind us of something we might fear we're losing; these are one kind of viral content.
Altaf is one such man who rides an auto rickshaw in Mumbai.
Earlier this month, entrepreneur Shubham Gune shared an average incident, which quickly found its way into public consciousness, as the founder and CEO of Hinglish. Gune rushed to a meeting with an international client at 7 in the morning and paid the auto-rickshaw fare by using Google Pay. The ride cost ₹156. But in his rush, he mistyped the figure as ₹15,682 and went ahead with the transaction anyway.
The rest of the story is what made this a nationwide discussion about integrity.
Gune's story is that the client meeting itself was a shit-show. He was disappointed because he felt that he had missed an important business opportunity. As he went outside, he saw the Auto Driver, Altaf, at the same spot. Altaf told him that the amount had been paid incorrectly, and he gave him back the whole amount. Not only the additional money, but also the total of ₹15682. Then, when Gune demanded that he still pay the original ticket price of ₹156, Altaf refused to comply with that, as reported, saying, "It's the morning of the day for both of us, sir! After a week, the client contacted us and decided to go ahead with the business. Gune later sent Altaf ₹500, his fare money and a small amount as a token of appreciation for his honesty.
On the surface, it's the tale of an honest man doing the right thing, a feel-good tale. Its meaning goes beyond that, though.
Altaf's decision is not just one of returning the money. It's that he did it when there was almost no reason for him to be honest. He might have been able to flee the scene in a busy metropolis of more than 20 million people. This was part of a completed transaction. There was little risk of short-term effects. He was presented with a chance to make money, and he would not take it.
In today's society, ethics are seen as a luxury item that only the wealthy members of society can afford. We assume that when it comes to making moral decisions, it is always weaker when economic hardship is present. Altaf's story is one that calls it into doubt. They remind us that a person's integrity has nothing to do with their income, education or social standing. It is a choice.
Another important truth is evident in the public reaction to the story. Everyone was no surprise at a piece of payment going awry because when anyone uses digital payments regularly, he or she knows that it is easy to make a mistake. The openness of the honesty surprised them. That reaction speaks volumes about what we collectively expect. This is nothing new to us; there are so many stories of scams, fraud and exploitation that basic decency is a rare occurrence.
That's why this incident really struck a chord with me. It was a sign of the trust that remains in everyday interactions.
More than most cities, Mumbai flourishes with unseen cooperation. Most people assume that everyone will adhere to basic social rules, which is why there is no issue with millions of people traversing full trains, buses, streets, and markets daily. The city is a place that works when strangers trust each other regularly. That trust is reinforced, even when it comes to the price of an auto-rickshaw, and it becomes news because it is a sign of a social contract that many worry is coming to an end.
But it isn't really a story of money. It is about value.
Altaf gave up ₹15,682. He received, in exchange, something that's priceless: Respect. His name is now known by thousands, who will never meet him. His action was a reminder that character is sometimes displayed in times when no one is looking.
The irony of it is, Gune lost the client that morning, for now at least, but he got a story that would last a long time to remember. When the client finally came back, his mind was instantly focused on the footpath where Altaf had waited, as he says, his mind was immediately turned to the footpath where Altaf waited.
Business deals can be brought back. There is the possibility of recovering revenue. Opportunities abound, and then they're gone.
But trust is established step by step over a series of decisions.
Altaf's selection is an almost radical simplicity in a world of efficiency, growth and profit. He saw money that was not his, and he gave it back. No speech. No performance. No expectation of reward.
The greatest acts are sometimes the ones that should be commonplace, but they don't seem that way anymore.
An entire country was reminded what honesty looks like by one man in Mumbai who drives a car. One auto driver showed an entire country what honesty is.
References