Not too long ago, I came across a social media post questioning why a local person spoke English with a foreign-sounding accent despite never having lived abroad. It was a passing observation on the internet, yet something about it did not sit right with me. Why should a person's accent become a reason for ridicule? And why should someone have to justify the way they speak simply because their experiences do not match our expectations?
We often forget that language is learned through exposure, practice, imitation and interaction. Someone who has never travelled abroad may have spent years listening to international speakers, watching television programmes or engaging with content in another language. Their pronunciation may reflect that exposure. An accent, by itself, tells us neither how intelligent a person is nor how capable they are of communicating. We may have preferences about how a language sounds, but those preferences should not become an excuse to belittle someone who speaks differently.
My own experience with Hindi made me recognise how much learning can happen outside a classroom. I was taught Hindi in school, but I picked up a great deal of the language by watching Indian television serials. The dialogues, recurring expressions and emotions attached to particular words helped me understand how the language was used in everyday situations. What I learned in class gave me a foundation; what I watched on television helped reinforce it. Looking back, I realise that learning did not stop when I closed my textbook. It continued while I followed stories on a screen.
I have also seen how entertainment can introduce people to languages they might not otherwise have explored. A friend of mine learned Korean through Korean dramas, gradually becoming familiar with words and expressions through repeated exposure. Such experiences do not mean that watching a show automatically makes someone fluent. Understanding a language, speaking it confidently and mastering its grammar are different achievements. Nevertheless, entertainment can spark curiosity, provide context and motivate a person to learn beyond what they already know. Sometimes, an interest in a story becomes the beginning of an interest in an entirely new language.
This raises a broader question: if we accept that people can learn from what they watch and hear, why do we so often dismiss screens as nothing more than distractions? The answer cannot simply be that screens are good or bad. Their influence depends on what we consume, how much time we spend consuming it, our stage of development and what that screen time replaces. A documentary, an educational programme, an endless stream of short videos and an age-inappropriate show may all appear on the same device, but they do not offer the same experiences.
The debate becomes even more complicated when children enter the picture. Some adults hand children a phone to keep them occupied while they finish work or manage other responsibilities. Others restrict digital devices because they worry about inappropriate content, reduced physical activity, disrupted sleep or excessive dependence on technology. Both groups may have understandable concerns, yet the discussion often becomes a contest between two extremes: unrestricted access on one side and complete rejection on the other. But are we asking the wrong question? Instead of arguing only about whether children should use screens, we should examine what they learn from them, what they lose when screen use becomes excessive, and what responsibility adults have in guiding that learning.
The evidence suggests that this distinction matters more than we might think. A systematic review and meta-analysis published in JAMA Paediatrics in 2020 examined 42 studies involving 18,905 children and found that greater screen-use duration was associated with weaker language skills. At the same time, educational programming and watching alongside caregivers were associated with stronger language skills. These findings do not prove that screen time directly causes poorer language development, nor do they establish that every educational programme is beneficial. They do, however, suggest that the quantity of screen use cannot be considered separately from its quality and context.
Consider what happens when a young child watches a programme that introduces unfamiliar words, names objects or presents a story through dialogue. The child may encounter ideas that are new, repeat phrases and begin recognising patterns in speech. Yet recognition is not the same as understanding, and repeating a phrase is not necessarily the same as knowing when to use it. Children need opportunities to connect what they see with the world around them. A conversation with a parent, an explanation from a teacher or the chance to practise a new word during play can help turn exposure into meaningful learning. The screen may introduce the lesson, but real-world interaction can help deepen it.
This is where the argument for educational entertainment needs to be balanced. A programme labelled educational is not automatically suitable for every age, and a child being occupied by a screen does not necessarily mean that the child is learning. Content that is inappropriate, excessively stimulating or simply consumed for long periods may offer little educational value. Moreover, time spent watching videos is time that cannot simultaneously be spent running outdoors, playing with other children, reading a book or talking with family members. The concern, therefore, is not that every minute in front of a screen is wasted. It is that an activity can become harmful when it begins to displace other experiences essential to a child's development.
The World Health Organisation's guidance on sedentary behaviour, physical activity and sleep makes this wider picture particularly important for children under five. For children aged two, and for those aged three to four, its recommendations limit sedentary screen time to no more than one hour daily, with less being better. The guidance also emphasises sufficient sleep and physical activity. These recommendations are age-specific and should not be treated as a universal limit for every child and teenager. Their broader lesson, however, is worth considering: children's well-being depends on the balance of their daily experiences, not simply on whether a device is present in their lives.
But there is another part of this conversation that receives less attention: the adults who introduce children to these habits. A child who repeatedly sees a parent reach for a phone during meals, conversations, or moments of boredom may come to regard that behaviour as ordinary. This does not mean every child who asks for a phone is merely copying an adult. Children are naturally curious, and their habits are also shaped by friends, entertainment, advertising and the design of the platforms they use. Nevertheless, the home environment matters. If adults expect children to put their devices away while remaining unwilling to do the same themselves, they create a contradiction between the rules they announce and the behaviour they demonstrate.
This is where responsible parenting must begin. Not with guilt, and certainly not with the assumption that every parent has unlimited time or resources, but with awareness. A phone can sometimes give an exhausted caregiver a necessary moment to finish a task, and that reality deserves understanding rather than automatic condemnation. The question is what happens beyond that moment. Are children being offered a variety of activities? Are adults paying attention to what they watch? Are there opportunities for conversation, play and rest? Most importantly, are the expectations placed on children reflected, at least in part, in the habits of the adults setting those expectations? A child may not follow every example set by a parent, but the examples surrounding a child help shape what feels normal.
The same principle applies to the books we encourage children to read. We often assume that reading is automatically a better use of time than watching a screen, but the value of a book depends on its content, its suitability for the reader and the way it is understood. A young child and a teenager do not have the same emotional maturity or capacity to interpret difficult themes. Some books introduce valuable ideas, while others may contain material that requires explanation and guidance. This does not mean children should be shielded from every uncomfortable subject. It means that adults should consider a child's age, understanding and individual needs instead of assuming that every book is appropriate simply because it is printed on paper.
Toys deserve the same thoughtful consideration. A toy does not become beneficial merely because it is marketed as educational, colourful or developmentally advanced. Research from the American Academy of Paediatrics has emphasised the importance of toys that encourage interaction, language, problem-solving and creativity, while noting that many advertised developmental benefits lack strong scientific evidence. A simple set of building blocks can invite a child to experiment, construct and start again. Pretend play can encourage storytelling and imagination. The value lies not only in the object itself but also in what the child does with it. A shelf full of expensive toys cannot guarantee meaningful play, just as a phone full of educational applications cannot guarantee meaningful learning.
There is, however, a danger in taking this argument too far. If we begin to believe that every book must be screened, every toy must be evaluated, and every moment of entertainment must serve an educational purpose, childhood can become an exercise in constant supervision. Children need boundaries, but they also need room to explore, make mistakes and develop their own interests. The aim of parental guidance should not be to eliminate every possibility of encountering something unfamiliar. It should be to help children gradually develop the judgement necessary to respond to unfamiliar ideas. Protection matters, but so does the ability to think independently when a parent is not present.
This brings us to a distinction that is often overlooked in debates about technology: restricting access and teaching discernment are not the same thing. Parental controls can help prevent children from encountering certain material, and limits on screen use can protect time for sleep, study and physical activity. Yet no filter can prepare a child for every situation they may eventually encounter online or offline. Children also need to learn to question what they see. Who created this content? Is it trying to inform me, entertain me or persuade me to buy something? Is the behaviour being presented as normal actually respectful? Does the information make sense, and can it be checked elsewhere? These questions turn media use into an opportunity to practise critical thinking rather than simply consume whatever appears on a screen.
The American Academy of Paediatrics' 2026 policy on children and digital media recognises that children's experiences are shaped by more than individual screen habits. Families, schools, digital platforms and wider social conditions all play a role. Many platforms are designed to encourage continued engagement, which can make it difficult for children and adults to stop scrolling. This means responsibility cannot rest entirely on parents or children. Families need practical guidance and support, while technology companies also have a responsibility to consider the needs and safety of young users. Telling a child to exercise self-control without acknowledging how digital environments compete for attention leaves out an important part of the problem.
So what should responsible parenting look like in practice? It can begin with small, consistent choices: selecting age-appropriate content, watching together when possible, discussing what appears on the screen, keeping meals and bedtime routines free from distracting devices, and making time for reading, conversation and outdoor play. It also means adults being willing to put their own phones aside during moments that deserve attention. These measures are not about creating a perfect household or expecting parents to supervise every second. They are about establishing an environment in which technology has a place without becoming the centre of every activity. Rules become more meaningful when children understand the reasons behind them and see adults making a genuine effort to follow them, too.
We can now return to the person whose accent prompted this reflection. We may never know how that person developed their way of speaking, and we do not need to know. They may have learned through television, online conversations, formal lessons or a combination of experiences. What matters is that an accent alone tells us very little about a person's intelligence, character or ability to communicate. If the intention is to understand how someone learned a language, curiosity would be a more constructive response than ridicule. If the intention is simply to make that person feel inferior, then the conversation has ceased to be about language at all. It has become a judgement about who is permitted to sound different.
There is an uncomfortable contradiction in the way we sometimes approach learning. We admire people who acquire new skills, yet question the methods through which they develop them. We encourage children to learn, but may dismiss the unconventional routes through which their curiosity grows. We expect them to become independent thinkers while sometimes treating unfamiliar interests as problems to be corrected. Of course, not every habit deserves encouragement, and not every form of imitation is harmless. The point is not to celebrate everything people absorb from their surroundings. It is to understand that learning is a process, and that judging its outcome without considering its context can lead us to unfair conclusions.
This is especially important in a world where digital media is becoming part of everyday life. Children will encounter information, entertainment and opinions far beyond what any parent or teacher can personally provide. Trying to control every possible influence is neither realistic nor sufficient preparation for adulthood. What they need is a combination of protection, guidance and the freedom to ask questions. They need adults who can explain why certain content is inappropriate without making curiosity itself seem shameful. They need boundaries that protect their development, but also conversations that help them understand the reasons behind those boundaries. Most importantly, they need to know that when something confuses them, they can ask for help without being ridiculed.
None of this means that parents should hand children unrestricted access to phones or that concerns about technology are exaggerated. Excessive screen use can interfere with sleep, physical activity, face-to-face interaction and other important parts of childhood. Some content is unsuitable, some online environments are harmful, and some habits require firm limits. Equally, banning every screen without considering its purpose overlooks the educational, creative and social opportunities digital media can offer. The sensible approach lies neither in blind acceptance nor in blanket rejection. It lies in understanding the child, evaluating the content, setting appropriate boundaries and remaining willing to adjust those boundaries as the child grows.
Adults must be prepared to examine their own assumptions before correcting those of the younger generation. We cannot expect children to develop thoughtful relationships with technology if we refuse to question our own. We cannot teach them to respect differences while making fun of the ways other people speak. And we cannot encourage independent thinking while treating every unfamiliar influence as a threat. Children will inevitably learn from the world around them, sometimes deliberately and sometimes without even realising it. Our responsibility is not to eliminate every influence, but to help them distinguish between what enriches their lives and what diminishes them.
In the end, the person with the unfamiliar accent and the child holding a phone may seem to have little in common, yet both remind us that people are shaped by what they encounter, what they practise and what they are encouraged to explore. A television serial may help someone understand a language, an educational programme may introduce a child to a new idea, a conversation with a patient adult may help either of them understand what they have learned. The same screen can also distract, mislead or consume time that could have been spent elsewhere. The difference lies not in the device alone, but in the content, the circumstances and the guidance surrounding its use. Before we mock someone for how they speak or blame a child for what they watch, we should ask a more useful question: what are we doing to help people learn well? Because the goal should never be to raise children who imitate nothing and question nothing. It should be to raise people who can learn from the world without losing the ability to think for themselves.
References: