Nathuram Vinayak Godse assassinated Mahatma Gandhi at a prayer meeting on 30th January 1948. He was put on trial for the murder of Gandhi, convicted, and executed in November 1949. Whilst it is clear who killed Mahatma Gandhi, the history of the people around him, especially the relationship with the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), Hindu Mahasabha and the politics of Hindu Nationalism leading up to Independence are points of debate.
The RSS was founded in Nagpur in 1925 by Keshav Baliram Hedgewar. It developed through local shakhas where volunteers would come together for physical exercise, discussion, and organisation. The RSS focused heavily on organisation and discipline, which helped the RSS become very popular amongst supporters. They believe that it was a tool for developing strong characters who are interested in social service and cultural pride. However, critics argue that the RSS promotes the idea of a Hindu Nation, putting religious majorities at the forefront of the nation but leaving questions over how religious minorities will fit into this ideology.
Godse’s relationship with the RSS is the most controversial aspect of this topic. Most agree that Godse was involved in the RSS in his earlier years and was also closely associated with the Hindu Mahasabha. However, the controversy surrounds whether Godse resigned from the RSS. During his Trial, Godse stated that he committed the murder himself and that he had resigned from the RSS. The RSS have used this statement to argue that Godse was not a member.
However, others have argued this. Gopal Godse, Godse’s younger brother, said in an interview with Frontline in 1994 that all the brothers were involved with the RSS and that Nathuram did not resign. He also believed that Godse made this statement to ‘save’ the RSS during the investigation after Gandhi’s assassination. Journalist Dhirendra K. Jha has researched the archives to show that there may not be any documents to show that Godse resigned. Many authors, such as historian Vinay Lal, have looked into the evidence.
As there are varying sources, researchers need to consider what the source is trying to achieve and the context. Godse’s statement from the court, Godse’s brothers' memory from many years after the event, the oral documentation, letters and investigative information all need to be considered. Although the testimonies from family members are significant pieces of evidence, they are not official membership records. The statement made by the accused in a politically charged trial needs to be placed into context. Due to this, historians and authors have come to various conclusions over whether Godse had resigned and, if so, exactly when.
Secondly, Godse was convicted of committing the murder. Although several other people were put on trial for their involvement in the conspiracy, Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, a high-profile Hindu Mahasabha leader with known connections to Godse, was also tried. However, due to not enough evidence being able to prove his guilt he was acquitted. The judgement did not find the RSS guilty. It is important to note that although there was evidence to show that Godse had ideological connections, personal connections and was arguably not a member, this does not mean he was legally responsible.
Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel wrote letters after the assassination expressing his concerns over the effect it had on the political atmosphere. He also made negative comments about the Hindu Mahasabha and RSS. This helps to show how high-profile leaders in the new Indian government viewed the organisation. However, this does not mean that the organisation was found guilty of plotting the crime.
The RSS was banned by the Indian Government in February 1948, following Gandhi’s assassination. However, they were unbanned in July 1949 after promises were made by the organisation, including creating a constitution. They were banned again during the 1975 Emergency and in 1992 after the demolition of the Babri Masjid.
However, with the organisation having its centenary year in 2025, there has been public debate over its role in Indian politics and society. In 2026, a minister in Karnataka, Priyank Kharge, commented on the RSS not being officially
registered and called for more transparency over their funding. RSS Chief Mohan Bhagwat disagreed with this, saying that it is not a legal requirement to register an association of individuals. This has nothing to do with the history of 1948 but instead focuses on the organisation’s legal and official status now.
It is important to note that whilst Godse murdering Gandhi is a known fact, Godse was known to be previously involved with the RSS and Hindu Nationalist organisations. There is controversy over whether Godse was an official member of the RSS. The RSS argues that they are not responsible. Critics argue that there are testimonies, research into the archives, and the political atmosphere. Although individuals were convicted, Savarkar was acquitted, and the RSS were not found guilty. A responsible account should clearly state all points.
References: