Image by Víctor Mendoza from Pixabay
A recent report by the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP), titled "Exodus: Is the Hindu Community Leaving Sindh?", sheds light on the growing migration of Hindu families from Sindh. This alarming trend is attributed to an unsettling combination of religious violence, economic instability and the far-reaching impacts of climate change.
Vulnerable Communities Facing Neglect
The HRCP report highlights the failure of the state to provide adequate protection for Hindu communities in Sindh. According to a post shared by HRCP on the social platform X, many Hindu families are being driven to leave their homeland due to persistent threats to their safety and livelihood. The study emphasizes that these migrations are not merely a response to faith-based violence but also a result of systemic economic struggles and environmental challenges, reflecting a broader neglect of this vulnerable minority.
Underreporting of Violence and Discrimination
During a presentation of the findings, HRCP Chairperson Asad Iqbal Butt pointed out a critical issue: the underreporting of violence and discrimination faced by Sindh’s Hindu communities. Despite the rising frequency and severity of such incidents, they often go unnoticed or unaddressed. This lack of attention exacerbates the already precarious situation for many Hindus in the region, further pushing them toward the difficult decision to leave their homes.
The Cost of Migration
For many Hindu families, migration comes with significant emotional and social costs. Leaving behind their roots, communities, and cultural heritage, these families embark on uncertain journeys often to India or other countries. While migration may offer them safety and stability, it also involves profound sacrifices such as separation from loved ones and the loss of their connection to the homeland.
A Call for Action
The HRCP report underscores the urgent need for state intervention to protect minority communities. The ongoing exodus of Hindus from Sindh highlights not only the state’s inability to address faith-based violence but also its failure to tackle broader socio-economic and environmental issues. Immediate steps must be taken to ensure the safety, dignity and well-being of minority groups by creating an environment where they can live without fear of violence or discrimination.
The findings serve as a reminder that safeguarding the rights and freedoms of minorities is essential to building an equitable and just society. The plight of Sindh’s Hindu community must not be ignored; it calls for collective action to address the underlying issues driving this forced migration.
Addressing the Challenges Faced by Hindu Communities in Sindh: A Detailed Overview
The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) recently brought attention to the significant challenges faced by Hindu communities in Sindh, highlighting the role of provincial and federal authorities in addressing these issues. A meeting organized by the HRCP shed light on various pressing concerns with input from key stakeholders and recommendations for meaningful action.
Extortion and Lawlessness in Sindh
Rajvir Singh Sodha, the special assistant to the Sindh chief minister for human rights underscored the growing issue of extortion targeting upper-caste Hindu families. Criminal gangs have been exploiting the already weak law and order situation in the province, leaving these communities increasingly vulnerable. Sodha emphasized that the inability to curb such crimes has deepened the sense of insecurity among Hindu families in Sindh.
The Plight of Hindu Women
Pushpa Kumari, a council member of HRCP has shed light on the specific threats faced by Hindu women in the region. Issues such as abductions, forced conversions and underage marriages were identified as ongoing and urgent problems. These challenges not only jeopardize the safety of women but also threaten the social fabric of the community. Kumari called for immediate interventions to address these human rights violations.
Call for Government Action
Journalist Sohail Sangi made an impassioned appeal to both the Sindh and federal governments, urging them to take decisive steps to improve the situation. He stressed the importance of:
- Strengthening law enforcement to prevent criminal activities.
- Increasing Hindu representation within the police force to build trust between communities and authorities.
- Establishing a consistent dialogue with local Hindu communities to foster a safer and more inclusive environment.
Recommendations for Long-term Solutions
The HRCP report proposed several key measures to ensure the protection and well-being of Hindu communities in Sindh:
- Collecting reliable data on the migration patterns of Hindus from the province to understand the scale of the issue.
- Deploying specialized law enforcement units in high-risk areas to enhance security.
- Introducing stronger legislation to tackle forced conversions and child marriages, ensuring strict enforcement of these laws.
Hindu Migration from Sindh: A Growing Concern for Human Rights
Reports of Hindu migration from Sindh, especially northern Sindh to various destinations like India have raised significant concerns among human rights activists and civil society organizations. This issue is not new but has grown more serious in recent years. In 2014, a Hindu parliamentarian revealed in Pakistan’s parliament that approximately 5,000 Hindus migrate to India each year due to security concerns. These migrations are often fueled by the worsening law and order situation in Sindh which has made daily life increasingly difficult for the Hindu community.
Fear of Lawlessness
A recent report highlights that over 300 Hindus from Kashmore district alone have fled to India, citing lawlessness and the threat of kidnappings by armed bandits. Such incidents reflect a broader environment of insecurity and fear that has gripped many Hindu families in the region. Despite these alarming developments, the government has largely dismissed the issue portraying it as a "conspiracy" against Pakistan rather than confronting the root causes of the problem. This approach underscores a troubling denial of the underlying challenges faced by the Hindu community.
Underlying Causes and Field Insights
Field research and interviews with Hindu community elders and members provide further evidence that migration from Pakistan to India has been a consistent trend. While the problem has existed for some time, its scale remains difficult to measure. The sensitive nature of migration often leads to underreporting or deliberate withholding of information, making it challenging to accurately assess the number of people affected.
Urgent Need for Action
The persistent migration of Hindus from Sindh to India is a reflection of deep-seated social and security issues that demand urgent attention. Without addressing the deteriorating law and order situation and ensuring the safety of minorities, the cycle of migration and fear is likely to continue. Recognizing and responding to these concerns with transparency and accountability is essential for fostering a more inclusive and secure environment for all citizens.
The session concluded with HRCP Sindh vice chair Qazi Khizer Habib expressing gratitude to the attendees for their participation and insights. The meeting emphasized the need for immediate and sustained efforts to address the challenges faced by Hindu communities in Sindh and ensure their safety and dignity. This call to action serves as a reminder of the importance of protecting minority rights and fostering harmony in a diverse society.
. . .
References: