The Indian central government has launched a significant investigation into a group of civil servants suspected of obtaining their prestigious positions through the submission of forged or illegal reservation certificates. This probe underscores the government's commitment to maintaining the integrity of the civil services and ensuring that deserving candidates are not denied opportunities due to fraudulent practices.
The Genesis of the Inquiry
The Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT), the central agency responsible for human resource management in the Indian government has initiated this inquiry. Their immediate action involves dispatching formal requests to various state governments. These communications specifically ask for a meticulous verification of the documents related to caste, income, and disability that these officers submitted during their application process. Initially, questions were raised concerning 22 civil services officers, but the DoPT has specifically targeted 15 for this thorough verification process.
Who is Under Scrutiny?
The group of officers currently under investigation represents a diverse cross-section of India's top administrative services. This includes:
- Two IAS (Indian Administrative Service) officers, each from the states of Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, and Haryana.
- One IAS officer each from Odisha, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, and Kerala.
- Two IPS (Indian Police Service) officials, both currently serving within the Ministry of Home Affairs.
- An IRS (Indian Revenue Service) officer stationed in the Revenue Department.
- An IFS (Indian Foreign Service) officer working in the Ministry of External Affairs.
The majority of these officers secured their positions between 2015 and 2023, indicating a recent timeframe for the alleged discrepancies. The certificates under examination pertain to various reservation categories, including Other Backward Classes (OBC), Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), Economically Weaker Sections (EWS), and Persons with Benchmark Disabilities (PwBD).
The Catalyst: An Activist's Persistent Efforts
This comprehensive inquiry was instigated following numerous complaints lodged by Vijay Kumbhar, a Pune-based Right to Information (RTI) activist. Kumbhar has consistently highlighted alleged irregularities in the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) selections and pointed out a perceived lack of robust verification mechanisms.
Kumbhar passionately articulated the impact of such fraud, stating, "Someone who genuinely deserved that seat is now out because someone else lied on paper. It’s not just a technical error, it’s a breach of public trust. The UPSC and DoPT systems need to be linked with real-time caste and income databases. Right now, there are too many loopholes." His remarks underscore the moral and systemic ramifications of these alleged actions, emphasizing the need for a more integrated and foolproof verification system.
Official Confirmation and Procedural Details
The DoPT's letters, dated May 5, 2025, and signed by Under Secretary Anshuman Mishra, specifically request state governments and central ministries to verify the reservation certificates. These include documents related to income and asset criteria for EWS and non-creamy layer OBC categories as well as SC and ST certificates, all submitted by the 15 officers during their UPSC selection. These letters also reference prior complaints forwarded by the UPSC, indicating a collaborative effort in this investigation. This coordinated, multi-cadre probe signifies a serious endeavour to address the alleged misuse of reservation benefits within the nation's premier bureaucracy.
A Precedent: The Puja Khedkar Case
The issue of fraudulent reservation certificates gained significant national attention following the 2024 case involving probationary IAS officer Puja Khedkar. She was ultimately dismissed from service after it was confirmed that she had submitted false OBC and disability certificates. Her case ignited public outrage and intensified calls for more stringent verification processes, likely serving as a crucial impetus for the current widespread inquiry.
This ongoing investigation by the central government is a critical step towards reinforcing public trust in the civil services and upholding the principle of meritocracy. It sends a strong message that any attempts to circumvent the system through fraudulent means will be met with rigorous scrutiny and appropriate action.
Future Disciplinary Actions and Lingering Concerns
The DoPT has made it clear that any further disciplinary actions against the 15 officers under scrutiny will be directly dependent on the outcomes of these state-level verifications. This step-by-step approach ensures that decisions are based on concrete findings from thorough checks.
Despite the ongoing inquiry, activist Vijay Kumbhar expressed a degree of dissatisfaction with the pace and nature of the action taken. He had initially raised these concerns in a letter to the President of India in 2024, but it went unanswered. The letter was subsequently forwarded to the UPSC, which by citing a lack of jurisdiction had passed the matter to the DoPT. To maintain pressure and ensure the issue remains in the public eye, Kumbhar has since filed three separate RTI applications.
Kumbhar's frustration is intense "I am still not satisfied that action has been taken by the department. This work shouldn’t be done by a citizen but by the concerned department. This is very shameful.” His statement highlights a broader concern about departmental accountability and the perceived burden on citizens to pursue such critical matters.
This ongoing investigation by the central government is a critical step towards reinforcing public trust in the civil services and upholding the principle of meritocracy. It sends a strong message that any attempts to circumvent the system through fraudulent means will be met with rigorous scrutiny and appropriate action.
The recent statements by Kumbhar shed critical light on the vulnerabilities plaguing India's reservation system, particularly concerning the Economically Weaker Section (EWS) category. His observations highlight a pressing need for comprehensive reforms to ensure both justice and merit prevail in the selection of civil servants.
Flawed Verification: A Gateway to Manipulation
Kumbhar's primary concern revolves around the absence of robust verification mechanisms. He points out that the current process for determining EWS eligibility relies on income and asset criteria that are often loosely monitored. This lack of stringent oversight, he argues, creates an environment ready for exploitation. His stark assessment, "The system currently allows manipulation due to subjective standards and fragmented verification", underscores how easily individuals can take advantage of the loopholes within the existing framework. The subjective nature of the standards, combined with a fragmented approach to verification, makes it difficult to accurately assess and confirm a candidate's genuine eligibility.
. . .
References: