During a coaching session, a client once asked me, “How does journaling help when I’m stressed, depressed, or overwhelmed by negative situations or hurtful people?” I had assigned her the task of identifying the sources of her negative thoughts by journaling daily. Initially, she embraced the exercise, diligently journaling for the first week. However, soon after, she expressed her frustration: “I don’t see any changes in my situation.”

My response was straightforward: “You won’t notice any change unless you commit to this practice consistently for at least three months.”

After that conversation, she stopped updating me on her progress, and I assumed our coaching agreement had quietly ended. This experience led me to reflect on why people are often reluctant to engage in the disciplined work of self-improvement. Why do they seek quick fixes through medication, doctors, counsellors, or coaches without fully embracing the process? It’s essential to recognize that meaningful change requires a commitment to a patient, sometimes challenging, journey—one that ultimately brings clarity and order to life.

Journaling is a habit that can have an immense positive effect on the human mind, more so than many other methods. However, because we often fail to allow sufficient time for the habit to become automatic, we miss out on its full benefits. Forming a new habit is much like the process of making ice cream. Just as children often peek into the freezer, impatient to see if their ice cream is ready, we too might be eager for quick results. But just as ice cream needs time to freeze and reach its true form, a new habit requires time and consistent effort to become as beneficial as we intend.

Studies suggest that forming a new habit can take anywhere from 18 to 254 days, with an average of 66 days before the behaviour becomes automatic. The popular notion that you can rewire yourself to a new habit in just 21 days is a myth. The reality is that the more disciplined and determined you are, the more likely you will be to successfully integrate the new positive habit into your life.

The Psychological Barriers to Journaling

People’s resistance to journaling often stems from discomfort with self-reflection, fear of vulnerability, or negative past experiences. Here are some key psychological factors that contribute to this resistance:

• Fear of Vulnerability: Journaling involves delving into personal thoughts and emotions, which can feel exposing. This vulnerability can be intimidating, especially for those who avoid confronting their feelings.
• Perfectionism: Some people struggle with the idea of not getting their thoughts “right” or worry about how their writing might look or sound. This perfectionism can prevent them from starting or continuing a journaling practice.
• Time Constraints: Many view journaling as a time-consuming activity, and in a busy lifestyle, it can feel like a lower priority compared to other responsibilities.
• Fear of Negative Emotions: Writing about difficult experiences or feelings can bring up painful emotions, which some might prefer to avoid. This can make journaling seem like a daunting task.
• Scepticism About Benefits: If someone hasn’t experienced the benefits of journaling firsthand or doesn’t see the value in the process, they may be sceptical about its effectiveness. Without a clear understanding of how journaling can help, they might not trust the process.
• Difficulty with Self-Expression: Some people find it hard to articulate their thoughts and feelings on paper. They might feel frustrated or overwhelmed by the idea of translating their inner experiences into words.
• Privacy Concerns: There may be a fear that someone else might read their journal, leading to concerns about privacy. This can cause reluctance to fully engage with the practice.

These psychological barriers can make journaling seem unappealing or even threatening, especially for those not accustomed to introspection or with unresolved issues they fear confronting. However, this does not have to be the end of the road. With the right strategies, these barriers can often be overcome, making journaling a more accessible and beneficial habit.

Strategies to Cultivate a Good Journaling Habit

1. Addressing Fear of Vulnerability

• Start Small: Encourage individuals to begin with light, non-threatening topics. Gradually, they can move into deeper reflections as they become more comfortable.
• Promote Self-Compassion: Remind them that journaling is a personal, safe space where they can be honest without judgment.

2. Overcoming Perfectionism

• Emphasize Process Over Perfection: Help people understand that journaling is about expression, not about writing a perfect piece. The focus should be on the act of writing, not on how it looks or sounds.
• Use Prompts: Providing prompts can reduce the pressure of coming up with ideas and can help focus their thoughts.

3. Managing Time Constraints

• Set a Time Limit: Suggest starting with just 5-10 minutes a day. Short, consistent sessions can help build the habit without feeling overwhelmed.
• Incorporate into Routine: Encourage journaling as part of an existing routine, like writing before bed or after morning coffee, to make it a natural part of the day.

4. Dealing with Fear of Negative Emotions

• Reframe Journaling as a Safe Release: Explain that journaling can be a safe space to process emotions, leading to relief rather than added stress.
• Focus on Gratitude: Starting with gratitude journaling can help shift the focus to positive emotions, making the practice feel less daunting.

5. Addressing Scepticism

• Share the Benefits: Provide evidence or examples of how journaling has helped others, emphasizing its role in improving mental clarity, emotional regulation, and personal growth.
• Experiment with Different Styles: Encourage trying various forms of journaling—such as bullet journaling, art journaling, or guided journaling—to find what resonates most.

6. Helping with Self-Expression

• Use Visuals: If writing feels difficult, suggest incorporating drawings, diagrams, or even collages. The journal doesn’t have to be all words.
• Encourage Freewriting: Recommend setting a timer and writing whatever comes to mind without worrying about coherence. This can free up self-expression.

7. Alleviating Privacy Concerns

• Ensure Security: Recommend using a password-protected digital journal or keeping a physical journal in a secure place.
• Suggest Anonymous Writing: Writing without names or identifying details can help alleviate privacy concerns.

8. Start with a Purpose: 

Identify a clear purpose for journaling, whether it’s for self-reflection, stress relief, or creative expression.

9. Be Consistent: 

Like any habit, consistency is key. Even writing a few sentences daily can establish the habit.

10. Track Progress: 

Periodically review past entries to see personal growth, which can reinforce the value of journaling.

11. Incorporate Reflection: 

Encourage taking a moment after journaling to reflect on the process and how it feels, which can deepen engagement.

Concluding, I can always empathize with those who find themselves resistant to journaling. The process of self-reflection can be daunting, and the fear of confronting deep emotions or the pressure of perfectionism may feel overwhelming. However, it’s equally crucial to understand that journaling is a tool for your growth and well-being. It’s not about producing flawless writing or uncovering every hidden feeling all at once; it’s about creating a safe space where you can explore your thoughts and emotions at your own pace.

Start, struggle, restart - but never stop!

.    .    .